1196: What's Yours is Mine

My good friend Mark and I played a bunch of Monaco: What's Mine is Yours What's Yours is Mine (damn it all to hell, I KEEP getting that the wrong way round) via the wonder that is the Internet this evening. It's rather fun.

If you haven't come across this peculiar little game before, it's essentially a multiplayer stealth game in which you cooperate to complete various heists as efficiently as possible. This isn't a ludicrously violent first-person shooter-style heist as in Payday: The Heist, however; no, these are missions where you have to sneak, think carefully about what you're doing and occasionally frantically improvise while being chased by a pack of slathering dogs.

Monaco's main distinguishing feature over many of its peers is its heavy sense of style. Levels are depicted from a top-down perspective as a black-and-white "blueprint" of the building the team are currently plundering, with only the regions visible to the player's current position "lit up" and showing their full detail. The rest of the blueprint is marked with various icons showing objects that can be interacted with, treasures to find and the eventual mission goal.

Controlling Monaco is extremely simple. Most actions are performed simply by walking into the object you would like to interact with — walk into a locked door to pick its lock, walk into a computer to hack it, walk into a safe to crack it. Each of the game's character classes, each of whom are unlocked over the course of the complete campaign, have their own special abilities that can help the team as a whole. The Lookout, for example, displays the locations of all guards and civilians (who alert guards) on the map when she is either standing still or sneaking. The Locksmith, meanwhile, can pick locks and crack safes more quickly, while The Cleaner can knock out guards or civilians that are unaware of his presence. Each level also has certain items that can help out — sometimes there are guns which can be used to kill guards, sometimes smoke bombs to sneak past, sometimes EMP grenades to disrupt electrical systems.

The interesting thing about Monaco is that it doesn't spoon-feed the player everything. You're given basic tutorial text through prompts on the floor as information becomes relevant, but the specifics are up to you to determine through experimentation. For example, on the last level Mark and I played this evening, we came across doors marked with a "hand" symbol that appeared to set off alarms if we successfully opened them. We subsequently discovered that these doors and the alarms could be bypassed by either hacking a nearby computer or cutting the power to the area they were in. The game didn't tell us this — we had to find it out for ourselves. I'm all for this.

This lack of spoon-feeding extends to the visual information provided to the player, too. The top-down display of what's going on is presented in a rather abstract manner, so you have to use your imagination to picture what's actually going on. In many ways, it's quite like a board game — albeit one you play in real-time — as you spend a lot of time looking at abstract representations of things rather than what they actually are. Nice little touches are there to stoke the fires of the imagination, however — the "blueprints" for the buildings are all marked with the names of each room, for example, so you can picture the purpose of each place you visit and why you're there. Some truly excellent (and easy-to-miss) ambient sound gives a wonderful sense of atmosphere to the whole experience, too. This is a game worth wearing headphones for, as just by using speakers you'll miss out on a lot of interesting audio cues.

Perhaps most pleasing is the fact that it's a cooperative game that can be played either online or off. Up to four players can cooperate with one another either all on the same computer, over a LAN or via the Internet. The game can also be played solo — and is a completely different experience when doing so, as you can't rely on the other players and their characters' abilities to back you up.

On the whole, it seems to be a really interesting game that I'm looking forward to trying again with friends. It's noticeably different from the "norm" and a lot of fun to play. It's also just twelve quid, so grab a copy today.

1194: Courting the 'Core'

Social games, it's fair to say, have a bad reputation among those who are euphemistically referred to as "core gamers". This bad reputation isn't altogether unjustified, of course — social games are, in many cases, derivative, exploitative or just plain boring — but despite the prevalence of Men In Suits (or, probably more accurately, Men In Trendy T-Shirts And/Or Turtleneck Sweaters) who have never played a video game before in their life running the show for the most part, there's a lot of talent in that particular sector of the industry.

So why the hell doesn't this part of the industry do more to attract the "core"?

It's at this point that, if I was talking about this in person with someone directly involved with the industry, that they would point to one of the following facts: 1) Candy Crush Saga having approximately 15 million daily active users; 2) CSR Racing on iOS earning somewhere in the region of $12 million a month when it launched; 3) The Top Grossing chart on iOS being dominated by games that are free to download.

These are all facts, and cannot be ignored. However, that doesn't necessarily mean that they're good things. As I've said many times in the past, just because you can do something doesn't mean you should. Candy Crush Saga has 15 million daily active users because it nags them via notifications to come back and play; CSR Racing earned $12 million a month by forcing people to pay up for "gas" for their cars if they didn't want to wait; and don't even get me started on what I think of the Top Grossing chart on iOS and the awful crap therein.

Aside from these matters, the fact that the social and mobile games sectors aren't courting the "core" more aggressively is just baffling to me. While those who identify as "core" gamers — i.e. those who will happily sit down in front of a computer or console for several hours at a time to use it as their primary means of entertainment rather than an idle timewaster — do not exist in as vast a number as those who have a Facebook account and who have tried Candy Crush Saga at least once, there are some important things to bear in mind.

Most crucially, of those 15 million daily active users that Candy Crush Saga has, only a tiny fraction of them actually pay anything. Some of them might pay a lot — these people are rather revoltingly referred to as "whales" by people in the industry — but an awful lot of them will either refuse to pay out of principle or just not enjoy the game enough to want to spend money on it.

Here's the thing: "core" gamers spend a lot of money. "Core" gamers will happily spent £40 on a brand new game without having read a review. "Core" gamers will pay a premium to get pointless cool stuff that they can show off. "Core" gamers are a lucrative source of income, in other words. Much as it pains me to break it down that way — I'd much rather games be seen as creative works than business products — it is, in fact, true.

So, then, I have to question why more of an effort isn't being made to make "core" gamers take social and mobile games seriously. Because it's not. "Core" gamers see the majority of social and mobile games as a massive joke — a festering boil on the arse of the industry; a source of interactive entertainment that doesn't create "proper games" and instead puts out the very worst sort of shovelware.

They're right, to an extent. So here's a few things the social and mobile sectors could do to be taken a bit more seriously by potentially one of the most lucrative markets out there.

Stop ripping the same things off all the time.

Seriously. Cut it out. We've all played Puzzle Bobble. We've all played Bejeweled. Stop trying to make out your puzzle game is new and innovative when, in fact, it is simply either Puzzle Bobble or Bejeweled (or, in a few cases, Jawbreaker).

If you must draw inspiration from past titles, that's fine; just stop drawing inspiration from such a small pool. Just in the puzzle game genre there are hundreds of great games begging for a social adaptation — Columns, Klax, Super Puzzle Fighter II Turbo, Puzzle League, Dr Mario, Baku Baku Animal… I could go on — so why are we constantly subjected to the same "match-3" bollocks over and over?

This isn't just an issue in the puzzle genre — social RPGs all rip off Mafia Wars; farming sims all rip off FarmVille; citybuilders all rip off CityVille, and none of them were actually that good in the first place.

Stop ripping yourself off.

If you already have a match-3 puzzle game in your portfolio, you don't need another one. King, currently the biggest social game company in the world thanks to the aforementioned Candy Crush Saga, is terrible for this. Now that Candy Crush Saga is the top performing game on Facebook, they've put out another game. What kind of game do you think that is? That's right; a game where you swap coloured things around to make groups of 3 in horizontal or vertical lines. Only this time they're fruit and vegetables!

Or how about Kabam, who have now released the exact same game with slightly different graphics and a different name four times (Kingdoms of Camelot, Kingdoms of Camelot: Battle for the North, Arcane Empires, The Hobbit: Kingdoms of Middle-Earth) and no-one (except me) has called them on it.

The fact that people buy into this is just depressing.

Hire some fucking writers.

Quite a few social games these days are very well presented, with quality graphics and decent sound and music. In many cases, they actually create quite an impressive atmosphere… until the player is asked to read anything and it becomes very apparent that the "plot" of the game, such as it is, was written by a dyslexic Russian 10-year old who had just played Magic: The Gathering for the first time.

Good writing is just as important as the more immediate parts of your game's presentation. Don't skimp on it. And even if you're not going for an epic plot in your game — incidentally, puzzle games do not need plots, so just stop trying to cram one in — at least get someone to proofread the in-game text, fix any typos and glaring grammatical errors… and make sure if you're releasing it in English-speaking territories that all of the game's text is actually in fucking English.

A shout-out to 5th Planet Games here, who actually make an effort with this sort of thing, even if the gameplay of the games sometimes isn't up to much; Legacy of a Thousand Suns may be a Mafia Wars ripoff in terms of gameplay, but at least it has some consistently well-written story text throughout, unlike Mafia Wars, which didn't even try in this regard.

Stop using outdated tech.

Adobe is winding down Flash support, so it's time for Web-based games to do the same. Relying on Flash means that you limit yourself to those using a computer that supports Flash, and excludes those on tablets and mobile phones. There are a ton of cross-platform solutions available now that allow you to deploy an app on the Web, mobile platforms and as a standalone PC, Mac or Linux executable, so there's really very little excuse for not using one.

Not only that, but your average computer these days is more than capable of dealing with some simple 3D graphics — in fact, most are more than capable of handling decent-quality 3D graphics. Unity is a solid option that makes porting between platforms a snap; use it.

Stop using stupid, inappropriate aesthetics.

This is what the artwork for the CSI Miami Facebook game looks like:

622367_325365960890338_170300072_oThis is a screenshot from the official House M.D. Facebook game, developed by the same team:

house_1And this is what a zombie looks like in the Walking Dead social game:

Social_Game_Zombie

 

I don't think I really need to say anything else on that note.

If it doesn't belong in the game, don't put it in the game.

You want to keep your players coming back day after day? Don't shoehorn in a stupid roulette game that makes absolutely no thematic sense whatsoever; instead, simply make a good game that people will want to keep playing.

Stop assuming I'm an idiot.

"Core" gamers have played games before. They don't need your tutorial to unfold over the course of the first 20 levels of your puzzle game. Make it brief, and make it skippable.

Along the same lines, it's okay to tell someone to do something and then not put a gigantic flashing arrow over the top of it and simultaneously darken the rest of the screen, just in case they missed the gigantic flashing arrow. Allow the player to experiment and discover things for themselves rather than pointing every single thing out to them. At the same time, provide a detailed Help file and/or tooltip system so that they can look things up if they aren't clear.

On a slightly different but related note, it's okay for games to be complex. Again, "core" gamers have played games before and are okay with complex mechanics. Important note: "complex" is not the same as "boring". Kabam and anyone else making "midcore strategy games", please learn this.

Make it so fun I want to pay, not so inconvenient I have to pay.

This is the biggie. Monetisation is the biggest challenge in free-to-play gaming in general, and particularly in mobile and social games, which often attract huge audiences but relatively tiny proportions of paying customers.

"Core" gamers do not like feeling nickel and dimed. Look at the negative response to stuff like Dead Space 3, or Real Racing 3 — both of which, not coincidentally, are by EA.

"Core" gamers also do not like having their time wasted. This does not mean that they will pay to bypass wait timers in your game; it means they will simply stop playing.

Provide "core" gamers with stuff they can buy that improves their experience, but which doesn't break the game. Throw out that stupid energy system — a "core" gamer will stop playing when they're good and ready, not when you tell them to stop. Throw out that "it takes three hours of real time to harvest your crops" bullshit — if you explicitly send them away, they won't come back. Instead provide them with cool stuff that they want to show off — new outfits for their character, new paint jobs for their car, new background music or even whole new levels or areas to explore. If you want a good example of how to do it right, look at stuff like DC Universe Online and Perfect World's free-to-play MMOs — all are satisfying to play for free, but all offer a ton of non-game-breaking benefits to those willing to pony up and buy some premium currency.

Talking of which…

Quit the "pay to win" crap.

"Core" gamers complain. A lot. Particularly when they believe that a game isn't being fair. They'll whinge about mages being nerfed, shotguns being OP'd and generally anything else that breaks the game balance. "Core" gamers play a lot of games and are thus very good at spotting when a game is unbalanced to an unfair degree. Do not make your game so that a crap player can buy their way to dominance over a skilled player; make it so the crap player wants to get better at the game. Reward the skilled player with cool stuff and allow the crap player to see all the awesome stuff they could earn if they were just a bit better; but don't allow them to buy their way to success.

Along the same lines, quit the "Get More Coins" nonsense. Part of the satisfaction of experiences like role-playing games and business sims for "core" gamers is feeling like they've struggled against all odds to earn their rewards. The second you allow them to simply purchase all the money in the game world for $50, you devalue those rewards and make them meaningless. You also, again, break the game balance. Instead, pace your game in such a way that the rewards are earned at a good, satisfying rate, and save the paid stuff for purely cosmetic items. If you must use a virtual currency for premium items, make it a completely separate currency that it's clear can only be acquired through spending money. Keep the "Cash Shop" stuff separate from the normal shop. And for heaven's sake stop plastering the screen with special offers and other sparkling icons — nothing breaks the atmosphere of your otherwise well-rendered fantasy world quicker than a large flashing icon bellowing about "20% Off Gems!"

____

I accept that many of these things are more difficult to implement than what is being done by many mobile and social games now. But they, among other things that I've undoubtedly forgotten — feel free to chime in in the comments — are why "core" gamers do not take mobile and social games seriously.

Court the "core" and you'll make a lot of money. Continue to alienate them, however, and you'll always be a big joke to a significant proportion of people who are willing to spend a lot of money on their favourite hobby.

 

 

1192: Take That!

(Because it's just too obvious to start a post about Ace Attorney with the word "Objection!" these days.)

I've started replaying the Ace Attorney series, largely because I recently reacquired the two installments I used to have in my collection that went missing when I loaned them to someone unknown a while back. (The person I thought I loaned them to swears blind he doesn't have them, and I believe him, sooo…) After finishing Lifesigns in all its Ace Attorney-esque glory, I was keen to revisit Nick, Maya and the rest of the gang for some happy fun times.

And I'm reminded why this is still one of my favourite game series of all time. It pushes all my buttons. Visual novel? Check. Adventure game elements (i.e. puzzles?) Check. Interesting characters? Check. Anime silliness? Check. Overdramatic music? Check.

It's testament to the quality of this game series that, even remembering most (though not all!) of the solutions to the various puzzles throughout, it's still a compelling experience I'm happy to sit through again, primarily because of the characters throughout.

Phoenix himself is a good protagonist. He doesn't enforce his personality on the player too much, but he's very much his own person rather than a blank slate. His growth from constantly-sweating, nervous rookie lawyer in the first game to confident giantkiller over the course of the entire series is heartwarming to see, and as I recall, taking down the villain in the final case of the third game was an immensely satisfying experience on a par with, say, defeating Sephiroth for the first time in FFVII.

One thing I like about the series is that it manages to successfully involve the player in a sense of "conflict" without ever resorting to violence. Not once does Phoenix draw a gun or any other weapon over the course of the game, yet the courtroom showdowns are as thrilling and exciting as any lengthy RPG battle sequence. This is one thing that actually improves slightly as the game progresses — in the first game, you simply have five "lives" in the courtroom sequences, whereas in later games you have a "health bar" that depletes by various amounts when you make an incorrect answer or accusation. This is a much better solution, as it allows for a storytelling trick that is unique to games — drama through interface. When the judge says that you'd better get your facts straight before you answer and you see that an incorrect response will drain your entire health bar in one go, you think damn carefully about what you're going to say next.

Ace Attorney is also pretty much the poster child for why it's a good idea to have a "companion character" with the protagonist — particularly if you're not going to go full-on visual novel and have them narrate everything they do. The chemistry between Maya and Phoenix — which successfully manages to get a cross a real sense of love between the two of them without ever once getting the slightest bit sexualised — is a real highlight of the series, and again it's something that grows and changes over the course of the three Wright games. It's a tradition that's continued in the fourth game Apollo Justice, too, albeit with a different companion character, and again in Ace Attorney Investigations (again with an all-new companion), which brings the wonderful Miles Edgeworth to the fore and inverts the series' usual format.

The game looks great on the big screen of the DSi XL, too. I'm rediscovering a bunch of great DS titles on those lovely big screens, and I'm really looking forward to playing the other Ace Attorney games in succession. It's actually been quite a few years since I last played them, and I don't think I've ever played all five one after another. I'll be interested to see how "coherent" they end up being. We'll see!

1190: Dev Diary 5

I've been thinking about interface design today. I told myself that I wouldn't faff around with the default RPG Maker bits and bobs too much so as not to hold up actually writing the story, but in practice it's so simple to tweak this stuff that I couldn't help myself. In doing so, I've immediately made a difference to the game that makes it look a little less like a half-arsed default RPG Maker project and has a bit more individuality, despite still largely using stock assets.

As a reminder, here's a typical shot of how it looked before:

oneyearlater5And here's how a different moment in the game looks as of today:

oneyearlater14Not a huge difference, I know, but the astute among you will notice two things: firstly, the colour of the text box has changed to a deep navy blue rather than the default gradient fill, and the main game screen now has a Persona 3-style "clock" in the upper-right corner of the screen, indicating what time of day it is. Presently, this only shows the time of day, but I'm toying with it showing what day it is, too — my hesitation on this note is that which day it is is only relevant for part of the game rather than the whole thing.

Earlier today, the "clock" was much bigger and looked a bit like this:

cRuISM7 - Imgur

 

I actually kind of liked it at the larger size, but it was overlapping the portraits of characters who appeared on the right-hand side of the screen a bit too much for my liking, so I reduced it a bit.

The reason I changed the colour of the text box was because I was experimenting with some scripts that changed the behaviour of the menu. Specifically, they allowed a "wallpaper" image to be applied, so my menu screen now looks like this:

oneyearlater10I figured I'd run with the "flat blue" colour scheme, and add a nice silhouette of Ami in the background for a bit of visual interest, and tweak the message box colour to match for consistency's sake. The silhouette image shows up nicely in the various menu screens without being too obtrusive, as you can see from this shot of the save menu:

oneyearlater15

In fact, it shows up particularly nicely when choosing to quit or return to the title screen — a happy coincidence of the fact that selecting this option darkens the screen somewhat:

oneyearlater16

Those of you who know RPG Maker well will also notice I've replaced the default font with the nice, simple and clean lines of Verdana. This was primarily to match the default font used in a message box script I'm using, because it was bugging me a bit that the font in my message windows and in the rest of the interface didn't match.

Oh, God. What is happening to me?

I jest. Fact is, today I'd reached a good natural "stopping point" in terms of composing the story, and it was as good a time as any to fiddle around with the "look" of the game a bit. I'm pleased with the effect it's had — they're only subtle little changes, but they've had a noticeable effect.

Now it's time to stop farting about with all this and move the plot onwards. To give you an idea of how things are going, the game is structured in several parts: firstly, there's a prologue; then there are five in-game days, during which a whole host of different things can happen according to exclusive choices the player makes in each of the morning, afternoon and evening time slots; then there are four unique "second parts" to the game, and one "true ending". So far, I've completely and totally finished the prologue, and I've finished the morning of the first day. If you're actually reading all the text like a normal person and not fast-forwarding it like me when I'm testing (yes, there is a fast-forward function) then there's probably just under an hour of Stuff to Do and Read so far. After I've created various environments once, I can reuse them for other events, which means that development will continue to accelerate as I progress through the story.

oneyearlater11Environments like the one seen above are quite complex, and most stuff in the game is "examinable", so there's a lot of flavour text in there. Now it's done, though, if I want Ami to come back here with another character — which I probably do — I don't have to design that map all over again. Which is nice.

Anyway. I'll leave that there for now. Just wanted to share how things were going!

 

 

 

 

 

1189: Lifesigns Critical

I completed a playthrough of the DS game Lifesigns last night, wrapping up a pleasantly satisfying experience that I enjoyed very much as a whole.

For those who haven't read my past enthusing on the subject, Lifesigns is an Ace Attorney-style adventure game/visual novel for the DS that happens to be set in a hospital and occasionally involve surgery sequences using the DS' touchscreen. Unfortunately for the game, on its original release this caused it to be compared unfavourably (and unfairly) to Atlus' excellent Trauma Center: Under the Knife, and as such it was passed over by many due to some rather middling reviews that missed the point somewhat.

Lifesigns proved to be a great experience for me, though, and it made me think about all the potential genres of gaming we simply don't get all that often. And when I say "genre", I'm not referring to whether something is a shooter or a platform game or an adventure — I'm talking about subject matter. Lifesigns is a medical drama, pure and simple, and that's something we simply don't get much in the gaming space. Trauma Center approaches it, but then veers off into crazy sci-fi town partway through — though the more recent Trauma Team does a much better job at remaining at least semi-plausible rather than going quite as batshit as its two predecessors. Then there was 1988's Life and Death and its sequel Life and Death II: The Brain, but both of those were more simulations of the surgical aspects than narrative-centric medical dramas. And don't even get me started on Surgeon Simulator 2013 — hilarious it may be, but realistic medical drama? No no no.

As you have probably gathered from my past enthusing on the subject, the strange and wonderful land of visual novels is one of the most forward-thinking subdivisions of the games industry in this regard. In visual novels, we have "slice of life" games that are about interpersonal relationships (too many to name); games about suffering with chronic conditions (Private Nurse); games about supporting people with terminal illnesses (Kana Little Sister); games about being a member of a rock band (Kira Kira) and plenty more besides. The freedom to pursue these rather unconventional subjects — unconventional for gaming, anyway — is due to visual novels' strong focus on narrative over gameplay rather than the other way around.

But that doesn't mean that there can't be any of what we'd traditionally call "gameplay" in there — Lifesigns is a great example of how you can keep something narrative-focused and still provide the player with things to do. The player has the option to move between different locations at will rather than being railroaded around the place by a completely linear plot; the player can ask various characters about pieces of information they have gathered; the player occasionally has to convince various characters to do or think things by presenting them with appropriate pieces of information; and, of course, the player has to pick up the scalpel and perform everything from appendectomies to emergency open-heart surgery.

Basically I think what I'm trying to say is that I'd just like to see more games about relatively mundane subject matter — and they don't have to be visual novels to be that way. I want to see an interactive sitcom in which you play one of the characters and interact with the others, but in which nothing of earth-shattering importance happens. I want to see more interactive medical dramas. I want to see more games like Ace Attorney where the focus in criminal investigations is on the lawyers, not the police or private detectives. I want to see more "slice of life" games like Cherry Tree High Comedy Club. And, should I find myself never having to look down the iron sights of a realistically-rendered machine gun ever again, I most certainly won't be sorry.

Note that as ever, I'm not saying that massively popular subsections of gaming such as competitive first-person shooters should go away. But I am saying that those of us who prefer something a little more sedate and cerebral should be catered to a bit more, that's all. We're getting there, slowly — I've certainly found enough to keep me entertained without even looking at the triple-A sector for a very long time — but there's still some distance to go before the same people who tune in to House every week are picking up a controller to play a new Lifesigns game.

1188: What the Hell Does 'Qoga' Mean Anyway?

So, I still have one ending of Ar Tonelico II left to see, but given that seeing it involves playing through approximately 85% of the game again, I decided to start the third Ar Tonelico game — the curiously-named Ar Tonelico Qoga — in the meantime. Also, I was waiting for my new old PS2 and my new copy of Ar Tonelico II to arrive before I returned to the lands of Metafalss, so it just made sense to try out the sequel while I waited.

And… gosh. The Ar Tonelico series' jump to "next-gen" consoles (how dated that sentence will look in a few months) meant that the team at Gust et al clearly decided to let loose with their wildest fantasies and build something that is, frankly, off the chart in terms of JRPG weirdness. And that's just within the first four or five hours; I've barely got anywhere with the story yet.

38-Qoga-00033Within the first five minutes, you're thrown into combat against what is either a big muscly man dressed in a cheerleader outfit or an incredibly masculine woman dressed in a cheerleader outfit (I haven't had that particular question conclusively answered yet), only to be followed by a tough-looking swordswoman inexplicably shapeshifting into the adorable young Reyvateil Saki, who regularly refers to herself in the third person and apparently has the ability to transmogrify assailants into cake, but at the expense of some of her memories. An hour or two later, you meet another Reyvateil named Finnel, who is a waitress at a local bistro, but who has somehow managed to get herself stuck halfway up a cliff a very long way away from where she is supposed to be. Also, there's some business with a master assassin who is dressed like a jester, one of the party members is clearly actually [SPOILER REDACTED] from [SPOILER REDACTED] rather than who they say they are, and somewhere along the line Reyvateils "discovered" the fact that if they take their clothes off, their magic gets more powerful due to their bare skin being able to absorb more magic from the tower, or something.

I would like to reiterate that I am approximately four hours into the game so far, and already this is the calibre of insanity we're dealing with. I shudder to think where this one is going to end up.

While none of the above descriptions are exaggerations, though, I have to say that the game appears to handle itself just as well as the previous entries in the series. It's got a self-consciously silly element, yes, and that's even more pronounced than the two PS2 games, but at the same time it also takes itself seriously when it needs to. Ar Tonelico Qoga's setting is a curious inversion of the first game's power structure in particular; whereas in the original game, Reyvateils were often treated as little more than servants to do their masters' bidding, in Qoga it's the Reyvateils (or, more accurately, the Clustanian Reyvateils) who wield all the power, regularly inflicting acts of genocide on humankind in the name of "Cleansing" an area. It's interesting to see the difference this makes to the dynamics of the game world — while I'm not far enough to be able to comment on this in detail yet, it's intriguing.

In all three games, Reyvateils are enormously powerful entities, but the way in which they're treated is very different. In the first game, they are, for the most part, downtrodden and treated like crap; in the second, they are mostly respected but also feared, particularly if they become infected with the "I.P.D." condition that causes them to become uncontrollable and dangerous; in the third, it seems, they are the "enemy" — or at least some of them are, anyway. As the jaunts through the mental worlds of their Cosmospheres make clear, however, Reyvateils are complex beings, just like "normal" humans, and no two are alike — so to say "Reyvateils are evil" is as ridiculous an assertion as saying "humans are evil".

I can't comment that much more on the plot as yet, but it's shaping up to be interesting — and if they go where they're implying they're going in Ar Tonelico II's ending, I'll be very happy indeed.

What has taken a bit of adjusting to so far is the new battle system. Just like Ar Tonelico II shook up the battle system from Ar Tonelico's interesting (if very easy) combat, Ar Tonelico Qoga completely reinvents in-game combat once again, replacing the turn-based fighting of the previous games with real-time arena-based combat that requires you to attack rhythmically in order to build up the Reyvateil's enthusiasm and, well, make her clothes fall off. Sorry, "Purge". I haven't quite got my head around it yet as it's fast-paced and confusing (and challenging!) but it's certainly an interesting change from the previous games, and I look forward to discovering its hidden depths over time.

I'm looking forward to "Diving" into the two heroines and finding out more about them. Even the first levels of their Cosmospheres in this one seem to indicate that they're both, as the vernacular would have it, "dealing with some shit", so I'm intrigued to find out what makes them tick — and also to figure out how on Earth this whole new "Hyuma" system for programming their song magic works. I get the feeling it's going to be a long, bewildering and enjoyable journey.

1187: Dev Diary 4

This is actually more of a "writing diary" rather than a dev diary, because I'd like to talk specifically about the way I write, and how this relates to the game I've been making.

I've never been the sort of writer who plans things out in exhaustive detail. I know, I know, this is probably woefully self-evident from the nonsensical ramblings I've been posting here for the last 1,187 days (and more occasionally beforehand, too) but it works for me. It got me through all of school, all of university and what has so far been a relatively lucrative career in writing professionally.

Note that I'm not saying I don't plan things out at all. (Although some better planning would have probably avoided that awkward double negative right there.) No, instead what I tend to do is get things firmly in my mind in fairly broad terms, then "fill in the blanks" as I go along. It's not quite writing by the seat of my pants, but it's also not doing a detailed, bullet-pointed list of every single point I'm going to cover over the course of the complete piece. It gives me a sense of structure, but also allows me the flexibility to veer off in another direction if I want to. Those of you who have read my past month-long creative writing endeavours on this site will have likely spotted the points in the (largely improvised) narratives where I had what I thought was a great idea at the time and proceeded down that path with gay abandon, sometimes to discover I'd written myself into a corner and promptly had to dig my way out somehow. (Oh, God. I shouldn't have said that. You'll all be looking for those moments now.)

Anyway, how does this relate to One Year Later? Well, quite a lot, as it happens. Writing an interactive game isn't quite the same as writing a novel. Even writing a visual novel isn't quite the same as writing a regular novel, since you (usually) have to deal with branching plot paths and whatnot. In the case of One Year Later, there is a linear path of "story beats", for want of a better word, but each of those has several different possible things that could happen, and within those several different possible happenings comes a series of optional things that people might not see at all. These optional things let me play with various aspects of the characters while still allowing the plot to continue moving forwards.

This is all very vague, as I'm trying not to spoil things, but let me give you a specific example to make things a bit clearer.

Who wouldn't want to go and have breakfast with Dax here?
Who wouldn't want to go and have breakfast with Dax here?

Early in the game, the protagonist Amarysse wakes up bright and early in the morning and goes out into the city. As she's leaving the inn where she's staying, she's accosted by Dax, one of the other main characters, who invites her to go for breakfast with him. If she accepts, they go for breakfast, they have a nice chat and various tidbits of information about both Ami and Dax are revealed, after which time passes and it becomes the afternoon. If she refuses (or, more accurately, defers his invitation until she has all the information available to make a decision) then she can go out into the city streets, where she comes across Feena, another one of the main characters, who invites her to go shopping. The player can only pick one or the other during this particular "time slot" of the game; both focus on Ami and a different main character, and both have the potential to reveal some new information, but they also exclude each other.

Someone who wants to go shopping with Feena, obviously.
Someone who wants to go shopping with Feena, obviously.

This, naturally, presents a challenge in later scenes, where I can't really refer to information in scenes that the player might not have seen. However, what I can do is use the built-in game mechanics to determine whether or not Ami knows about a particular subject, and if she does, trigger some different (or additional) dialogue to if she was discovering this information for the first time. An example of this comes if Ami chose to speak to Feena earlier in the game and revealed the information that Feena is, for some reason, not as happy as she could be. In game terms, hearing this information for the first time rewards Ami with a "topic" item called "Feena's Worries"; later, asking Feena specifically about it when given the opportunity upgrades the topic item with new information (she's not happy with her work), allowing Ami to then automatically pick up on little things that Feena says about her work and put them in context — something that she doesn't do if she doesn't have any knowledge of the topic at all, or if she doesn't know that the thing that's making Feena antsy is her work.

It's very interesting (and challenging!) to write this way, as it really forces me to think about the characters and how they might have interacted in the past, and how that might inform their future interactions. One Year Later is a game all about dialogue and interpersonal relationships, so it's important to get this right. I hope I do!

This particular piece of dialogue only shows up if, indeed, Amarysse discovered Feena's real age the previous night -- an optional bit of dialogue that some players might miss.
This particular piece of dialogue only shows up if, indeed, Amarysse discovered Feena's real age the previous night — an optional piece of information that some players might miss.

What this brings me on to is something I suddenly noticed very consciously earlier on while writing some optional, missable incidental dialogue between Ami and Feena: I very much get "into character" while writing.

I say I noticed this earlier; I've actually been conscious of it for quite some time when doing more traditional writing — it's one reason why I enjoy writing stories from the perspective of a first-person participant narrator — but it seemed particularly pronounced earlier. I very much felt like I was "inside the heads" of both Ami and Feena as they talked to each other about, frankly, fairly mundane things — things that those racing through the game would miss, but which those who wanted a deeper understanding of these characters would appreciate as a reward for thorough exploration and investigation.

The thing to be careful of when feeling like this, of course, is getting that characterisation across to the player, who doesn't "know" these characters in quite the same way as I do. Since while I'm writing the dialogue between these characters I'm effectively "role-playing" them, hopefully this will give the dialogue a reasonably natural-feeling flow. This is something that I won't be able to tell for sure until someone else who doesn't know these characters at all plays the game — which is a scary prospect, for sure!

Anyway. That's it for today. I've been doing some good work on the game recently and making some good progress. There's not enough there to proudly show off in playable form yet (though there is just under an hour of "Stuff to Do" implemented now, which feels a significant amount!) but there will be before long. In the meantime, I intend to post some occasional thoughts on the subject of its development on this 'ere blog as I (hopefully) continue to make progress.

One day you might even be playing it. Who knows?

1186: Don't Hate

There's a curious phenomenon in comments sections around the land. And that phenomenon is that it is seemingly the law that someone, somewhere, must hate everything. Actually, that's badly phrased; I don't mean that one person hates everything — though I'm sure there are people who do — but instead I mean that whatever the thing that has been posted, there will always be at least one person who dislikes it for some reason and is inevitably the sort of person who is very vocal about their dislike of it.

This seems to happen particularly frequently in sectors that already have passionate userbases, or in which the userbases are seen as being a "subculture" and/or outside the "norm" somehow. I'm thinking specifically of the video games and anime sectors here — and before you start on me, for all the massive steps forward these media have made in terms of mainstream acceptance over the last 20-30 years they are still indelibly tarred with the "geek" brush to one degree or another.

Today, I was exploring the RPG Maker community who, by all accounts, appear to be a fairly friendly and helpful bunch for the most part, as I've previously mentioned. I was curiously browsing through some of the other users' projects in progress and came across a few interesting-sounding games. One of the users noted that they had submitted their game to Steam Greenlight, the process whereby a game can end up being sold on Valve's popular PC gaming digital download storefront if it gets enough positive votes from the community.

The game, by all accounts, sounded interesting and unconventional, and something I'd be intrigued to play. It was an "artistic" game, for want of a better word, designed as a means for the author to show what it was like living with depression. The author said upfront on the site that it was a mostly-linear, narrative-centric experience with a lot of text, and made no apologies for this fact. (For people like me, the terms "narrative-centric" and "lot of text" are selling points, not things to be ashamed of!)

Sadly, the Greenlight comments section was less than supportive for various reasons, featuring disparaging remarks for everything from it being "another depression game" (oh, sorry, there have been so many of those) to dismissing it simply because it's an RPG Maker game. I've made my feelings on the latter point quite clear in the past, but they bear repeating: if a tool is available to help someone realise their artistic vision, there's no reason why they shouldn't use it, regardless of how many other people are also using it. And besides, some of my favourite games in recent memory have been RPG Maker titles — Corpse Party, To The Moon, Cherry Tree High Comedy Club… all of them were made in earlier versions of RPG Maker that were considerably less sophisticated than the excellent toolset that is VX Ace.

But I digress. The point is that the comments section was filled with hate for the sake of hate rather than actually constructive feedback. The fact that the game in question (Actual Sunlight, I believe it was called) was "another depression game" and an RPG Maker project had nothing to do with its quality, or its "value" to the Steam community as a whole, and yet these things were used as reasons to reject it, without even bothering to check it out.

In the anime sector, it seems that it's fashionable to hate on whatever the biggest name show is at the time. Most recently, this has been seen with Sword Art Online, which I found to be a rollicking good time with an astonishingly spectacular soundtrack, some memorable characters and an interesting, intriguing and pleasingly mature (for the most part, anyway) storyline. It was a good show, in short; while it perhaps wasn't the most intelligent anime you'll ever see, it was certainly far more than a dumb, formulaic show.

Perhaps not something everyone would want to watch, no, but certainly far better than the overly-negative comments that would appear on J-List's Facebook page any time site owner Peter Payne posted a piece of artwork relating to SAO. (Granted, J-List's Facebook page is a place where any time a picture of a vaguely attractive anime girl is posted, one specific user will always be along within three comments of the start of the thread to helpfully inform everyone that "[he] would fuck her", so it's perhaps not the best place to go for objective criticism, but still; you'd expect a community of Japanophiles such as the followers of J-List's page to be a bit more enthusiastic about the things they supposedly like!)

I honestly don't get why this happens, and it seems to happen a lot. Why waste your time on hate when there is so much stuff out there to get you excited? Wouldn't you rather feel happy and intrigued by something than angry or upset?

1180: Dev Diary 3

I'm pleased to report that work on my game is continuing apace and even seems to be accelerating somewhat. This is very pleasing, as making progress is hugely motivating. Every time I add a new bit and it works properly, it feels good. Okay, I'm not doing anything massively complicated, unlike some of the badass scripters out there (some of whose work I've incorporated into this project for simple improvements to RPG Maker's basic functionality) but I am making something that's more than a completely linear path to the finish line. (To be fair, that can be challenging enough, depending on what you're doing!)

Anyway, I thought I'd share two more WOLD EXCULSIVE!! screenshots with you to give you a sneak peek at what's going on so far.

oneyearlater3Look at it being all night-time and stuff! Night-time effects are easy to create in RPG Maker thanks to the convenient screen-tinting command — this even incorporates various presets for times of day and weather conditions if you don't trust yourself to tweak the sliders.

If you'll recall my previous post where I shared a couple of images, you may recognise this as the other end of "The Strip," a road in the capital city where a lot of the game's business unfolds. In this shot, we see the complete party following Amarysse following an evening of debauchery in the Tail of the Dog on the right, and two creepy mages wandering around outside their mysterious guild tower. The one on the left is called Bill. He has sweaty armpits.

oneyearlater4Here's the "topic" system I talked about last time I wrote about the game. Ami and Dax here are having a late-night chat about various bits and pieces, and Ami's decided to ask Dax about some specific things she's got on her mind rather than just general chitchat. This "Ask" system won't be available for every conversation because that will just slow things down unnecessarily, but in situations where Ami is free to wander around and chew the fat with her companions — most commonly before everyone goes to bed — it will provide the opportunity to pick everyone's brains on various subjects and potentially gather some further information. The end of each day in the game will also provide the opportunity for Ami to reflect on the things weighing on her mind, and there will be events throughout where Ami will have to use the topics she's gathered to convince people of things or prove something. I'm taking strong cues from Ace Attorney and Lifesigns here.

Implementing this system was actually surprisingly easy without any need for delving into complicated scripting. Instead what I've done is I've replaced the staple RPG "Key Items" menu with a "Topics" menu, and simply added topic key items to Ami's inventory as they come up in discussions. The actual "Ask about…" functionality is a straightforward event call in RPG Maker that prompts the player to select one of their key items (or topics in this case). This event call stores the value of the item the player selected in a variable, which you can then check to see what was picked. All you need to do then is add some "conditional branches" to check if the item picked was [x], [y] or [z] and then display the appropriate exchanges between the characters — and just to cover all bases, add a generic event handler if the player picks something about which the character doesn't have anything in particular to say.

If that all sounds like gibberish, don't worry. It's actually just a series of simple, logical statements, though. If you were telling a person to handle what I've just described, it would go something like this:

Let the player pick one of the topics, and remember what it is. Was the topic they picked about "Feena's Worries"? If so, then play back the conversation on that subject; after that, forget the topic they picked and give them the opportunity to pick another one. Was the topic they picked about "Hiro X Lily?" If so, then play back the conversation on that subject; after that, forget the topic they picked and give them the opportunity to pick another one. Was the topic they picked something else? If so, then play back a generic conversation; after that, forget the topic they picked and give them the opportunity to pick another one.

Clearer? No? Well, never mind. I know what I'm doing, and that's the important thing.

Anyway, it's 1:30am and I must resist the urge to tinker and fiddle around with things (IN THE GAME) and go to bed. There'll be plenty of time for tinkering and fiddling over the weekend, particularly as I'm not friends with my PS2 any more — it scratched the bejesus out of my Ar Tonelico 2 disc to such a degree that the ending videos don't work at all any more. I've had to order a new copy (thankfully not that expensive) and I've also ordered an old-school PS2 fat (also thankfully not that expensive — the two items cost the same as a single new copy of Bioshock Infinite, which is quite amusing to me), as this scratching problem is apparently a known issue with PS2 Slims of a certain age. What that does mean is no Ar Tonelico 2 for a few days until those replacements arrive, so plenty of time to work on my own game. Or possibly just bum around with something else. Or start Ar Tonelico 3.

 

 

1179: Open for Browsing

A few days ago, the app AppGratis was pulled from the App Store for specific reasons unknown, but many conjectured it was due to the service that the company provided for developers — specifically in promotion of their apps. AppGratis, it was claimed, was gaming the system and manipulating the charts of the App Store so that they didn't really accurately reflect reality. I don't know whether or not that's actually true, but it's plausible given the shadiness of some parts of the mobile sector.

What I do know, however, is that the App Store charts are useless anyway, largely due to the huge amounts of miscategorisation (is that a word? It is now) going on, making it absolutely impossible to browse and find something you're looking for.

But is it really that bad? I decided to do a little experiment to see how accurate the descriptors in the Games category — the only App Store category to have subdivisions — actually are. Let's take a look at the Top 10 in a selection of these categories and see if the games therein actually belong in those groupings, shall we? Wait, where are you going…?

Huh. Sod those guys, we didn't like them anyway, right? Here we go, then.

Adventure Games (Paid)

Wikipedia's definition of adventure games:

An adventure game is a video game in which the player assumes the role of protagonist in an interactive story driven by exploration and puzzle-solving instead of physical (e.g. reflexes) challenge.[1] The genre's focus on story allows it to draw heavily from other narrative-based media such as literature and film, encompassing a wide variety of literary genres. Nearly all adventure games (text and graphic) are designed for a single player, since this emphasis on story and character makes multi-player design difficult.[2]

  1. Temple Run Oz — not an adventure game, it's an action/arcade game
  2. Minecraft — not an adventure game, it's a… Minecraft
  3. Badland — not an adventure game, it's a platform game
  4. Doodle Jump — not an adventure game, it's a platform/arcade game
  5. Grand Theft Auto: Vice City — not an adventure game, it's an action game
  6. Temple Run Brave — see No. 1
  7. Dead Crossing — not an adventure game, it's a shooter/driving game
  8. Eden — not an adventure game, it's a Minecraft-alike
  9. Clear Vision — not an adventure game, it's a sniper-centric shooting game
  10. Blue Toad Murder Files — HOLY SHIT AN ADVENTURE GAME

One out of ten is correctly categorised. So that's not all that good, really, is it? Let's look at the free adventure games.

Adventure Games (Free)

  1. Gangster Granny — shooter
  2. Temple Run 2 — See No. 1 in the Paid category
  3. The Simpsons: Tapped Out — citybuilder
  4. The Sims: FreePlay — It's The Sims, but more boring
  5. The Croods — citybuilder/farming game
  6. Frontline Commando: D-Day — shooter
  7. Minecraft Lite — Minecraft
  8. Jail Break Now — vaguely adventure-ish
  9. Tap Paradise Cove — citybuilder/farming
  10. Nimble Quest — Snake with a twist

Nope. Nope. Nope. One out of ten, and that might not even count as it's more of a stealth game. Let's look at a favourite genre: role-playing games.

Role-Playing Games (Paid)

Wikipedia again:

A role-playing game (RPG and sometimes roleplaying game[1][2]) is a game in which players assume the roles of characters in a fictional setting. Players take responsibility for acting out these roles within a narrative, either through literal acting or through a process of structured decision-making or character development.[3] Actions taken within many games succeed or fail according to a formal system of rules and guidelines.[4]

  1. Slayin — arcade game with RPG elements
  2. Gemini Rue — THIS IS AN ADVENTURE GAME WHAT THE FUCK IS IT DOING IN THE RPG SECTION
  3. Mighty Dungeons — old-school dungeon-crawler. It counts.
  4. Skylanders Battlegrounds — Sort of RPG-ish, but more action game than anything
  5. Dentist Surgery Game — NO. Not even a little bit.
  6. Minecraft Explorer Pro — Not even a game; this should be in the Reference section.
  7. World Explorer – Made for Minecraft — Crap Minecraft clone. Not an RPG.
  8. Monster Wars — Strategy game
  9. Surviving High School — Visual novel/adventure game, not RPG
  10. Minecraft Papercraft Studio — Not a game at all

Hmm. Slightly better. Still not great. And the presence of Gemini Rue in there just feels like the App Store is mocking me for writing this. Let's look at the freebies.

Role-Playing Games (Free)

  1. Beauty Dentist — NO. (Also what the fuck is up with all the dentist games?)
  2. Tekken Card Tournament — Vaguely RPG-ish, but no. It's a card game. There is a card game section.
  3. Mighty Monsters — Pokémon ripoff. Crap, but could accurately be described as an RPG.
  4. Come on, Zombie! — More of an RTS than an action RPG, but I'll allow it.
  5. Campus Life — Poor-quality The Sims knockoff.
  6. Campus Crush — Visual novel/dating sim, not RPG
  7. Dungeon Hunter 4 — Yes!
  8. My Beauty Spa — No!
  9. Epoch — shooter
  10. Crime City — Citybuilder wanting to be edgy, actually just crap. Not RPG.

Oh dear. (And seriously, people, why all the virtual dentistry?)

What about board games? I like board games, and there are some good adaptations on the App Store, I know that for a fact. So what do the charts look like?

Board Games (Paid)

  1. Monopoly — Yep
  2. Scrabble — Yep
  3. Words With Friends — Yep
  4. Monopoly Here & Now: The World Edition — Yep
  5. Trivial Pursuit — Yep
  6. The Game of Life — Yep
  7. MahJong — Please learn the difference between "Mahjong" and "Mahjong Solitaire", but yep
  8. Pentix: warning! this developer likes to put stupidly long titles in things in the hopes of making their game look better! — Nope
  9. Doodle God — Nope
  10. Risk — Yep

Much better. Not perfect, but better. Shame all the top-selling ones are crap board games, though. Seriously, people, two different varieties of Monopoly? I don't mean to sound like a board game snob (actually, I do) but there are far better games out there. But at least it's actually in the right fucking category.

Board Games (Free)

  1. 6 Numbers — Countdown ripoff. More of a puzzle game.
  2. Lazors — Again, more of a puzzle game, but there is a board game a bit like this.
  3. Bingo — Nope. To the Casino section with you! Away, filth!
  4. Four In A Row 2013 — (Spoiler: it's the same as Four in a Row has always been) Yep
  5. Words With Friends Free — Yep
  6. Monopoly Hotels — NOPE. This is a shitty Monopoly-themed building game, not a board game. Sadly, there isn't a "shitty building game" category, but it would better belong elsewhere.
  7. Sudoku — Puzzle, not board game.
  8. Ruzzle — Yet another Boggle ripoff, but yep
  9. Chess Free — Yes!
  10. Friendle — Live Board Games with Friends and Family — The clue's in the name!

Again, better. But again, crap that has nothing to do with board games (except the name in Monopoly Hotels' case) is in the board games category.

So the situation varies a bit from category to category. But it should hopefully be clear from that that there are some significant problems there. Imagine you really want to play an adventure game on your iPhone or iPad — something like the excellent Gemini Rue or Broken Sword. Browse through the adventure game category and you may well have trouble finding things that are actually adventure games. That's a problem.

Sadly, without a complete wipe of the App Store's catalogue and recategorisation of everything, I think we're too late to really do anything about this. Developers deliberately submit their titles to the wrong categories to get greater visibility, and this effect spreads as more and more people do it — and in the meantime, Apple don't appear to care all that much when things are incorrectly categorised. The whole situations is a big ol' mess, and I'm not surprised independent developers working on genuinely great games are enormously frustrated that it's impossible to get their stuff seen amid all the other shite.