One of the things that people seem most hesitant to do these days is to make their own mind up about things — particularly when it comes to opinions on popular media.
To simplify the model, some people find themselves in the role of "opinion leaders", and people who follow those opinion leaders take said opinion leaders' opinions at face value without taking the time to think critically for themselves.
This has, to an extent, always been an issue in one form or another. I vividly remember back in the '80s and early '90s taking the word of magazine reviewers as absolute gospel, for example, and yet in more recent years I've come to the conclusion that modern video game reviews are, for the most part, completely and utterly useless to me.
The reason I'm bringing this up now is that I've just finished a recording session for Atari A to Z. One of the games I was covering was, supposedly, a hot pile of garbage that had no redeeming value whatsoever — at least, if the reviews both at the time of its original release and a little later (early 2000s) were to be believed.
But then I played it… and while it had its limitations — it was still an Atari 2600 game, after all — there was actually a lot to like about it. And I'd go so far as to say that calling it "bad" would be doing it a massive injustice. You might not like it, you might find it boring or you might simply find it unappealing, sure… but from a technical standpoint, this game was pretty much flawless.
And herein lies the problem we've always had with video game criticism specifically: the fact that the "opinion leaders" (or wannabe opinion leaders) out there are still obsessed with making judgements of "quality" on something that is fundamentally subjective. Bad games absolutely do exist, sure… but there's a limit to what you can reasonably call "bad" before you're crossing over into "I just don't like this" territory. Which is quite a different territory, let me tell you.
Anyway. It's always a pleasant surprise when I cover something I'd been led to believe would be a pile of old toss, and it actually turns out to be rather enjoyable. You can find out what it is in a couple of weeks' time on Atari A to Z Flashback!
