Who could have possibly predicted that the release of supposedly The Most Important Video Game of All Time would attract the sort of rancid, toxic discourse, the likes of which we haven't truly seen for many years? Everyone. Everyone could have predicted this. But it is both mildly surprising and inevitably depressing that it is just the same old talking points over and over again.

I'm not going to get into the specifics of the things that are being said, because they are the same old, same old bullshit that has been coming up since the dawn of time… or at least the Internet. Actually, earlier than that, because a significant part of it all has been, of all things, review score discourse. Yes, people are still arguing about the completely arbitrary number that certain publications put at the end of their reviews.
I'll spoil something for you here: these numbers are picked pretty much entirely on vibes. There is no science to it and there is certainly no consistency between publications. I watched an excellent episode of the FunFactor podcast recently where they looked at an Australian games magazine, and said mag regarded the entirety of the 0-49% mark as "bad". That's half of the entire grading scale! Other publications, meanwhile, make a point of saying that "50% is average", whatever "average" means… and then inevitably don't stick to it, because neither Metacritic nor the general public believe that something rated 50% or lower has any redeeming features whatsoever.
It's all so thoroughly silly, and it's been both humorous and depressing to see how predictable the talk has been. Complaining over frame rate? Check. Complaining about "woke"? Check. Complaining about reviewers getting paid off? Check. It's like we're back in the early 2000s. Only, somehow, worse.
Actually, I'm not sure that's fair. The 2000s, for me, represented one of the best times to be talking about games online. It was the heyday of 1up.com, still my favourite gaming site of all time (and not just because of the family connection). 1up.com did something that no other games site has succeeded at doing in quite the same way: it allowed subcommunities and subcultures to form, and those subcommunities thrived without feeling the need to arbitrarily declare war on one another for no real reason.
I think it was a little later that the absolute worst of Online Discourse started. I suspect it coincided with the rapid growth of social media, and the way in which clout-chasers could "earn" validation by posting the most inane garbage, designed to rile people up.
Although that's always happened, too, hasn't it? I remember when we first got "The Internet" at home, and I started to learn some of the "lingo" that surrounded it — "flaming" and "trolling" have been around since the earliest days of Usenet and, I suspect, even bulletin board systems.
Maybe we, as human beings, just shouldn't be allowed to interact with people via any means other than face-to-face. Because, as the meme goes, a lot of people online are willing to say things behind a veil of anonymity that would get their fucking face caved in if they were to say it in "real life".
I'm not sure what my conclusion to all this is. Probably that everything sucks, and the longer time goes on, the more it feels like things stay the same or even get worse. Surely we're due an upswing of people not being shitty to one another soon…?
Not today, though. Not today.
Want to read my thoughts on various video games, visual novels and other popular culture things? Stop by MoeGamer.net, my site for all things fun where I am generally a lot more cheerful. And if you fancy watching some vids on classic games, drop by my YouTube channel.
If you want this nonsense in your inbox every day, please feel free to subscribe via email. Your email address won't be used for anything else.