You know, for literally years at this point I've been saying I don't give a shit about Grand Theft Auto VI. And it was true. I was sick of the sight of Grand Theft Auto V by the time it came to PlayStation 4, let alone PlayStation 5, and I maintain that Grand Theft Auto Online is one of the most miserable multiplayer experiences I have ever had, outside of a few improvisatory sessions with friends that weren't really engaging with the broader metagame. Between those things, I had pretty much written off the series — particularly after not really enjoying IV all that much, and of just thinking V was sort of… fine.
But this evening in particular I've found my feelings softening somewhat. I've been hearing some genuinely interesting things about Grand Theft Auto VI. A friend of mine who I reconnected with last week after a long time apart is loving his time with it. And I cannot help but wonder… am I just being stubborn for the sake of being stubborn here, or are there really any "principles" I feel that I am clinging onto by not playing it? Is my life being made in any way measurably better by resisting it?
It's hard to say. On the one hand, I resent the sight of Grand Theft Auto VI; of the fact that it is sucking up all the oxygen in the room; of the fact that it is likely to sweep the floor at the Game Awards, even though at the time its nomination was announced, only members of the press would have played it. On the other, as much as I resent it for those reasons, its release is a genuine cultural event in the gaming space. Some people are positing that it is unlikely we will ever see a game on this scale ever again — particularly with a single-player focus, which, interestingly, is something that is put at the very top of every piece of promotional blurb I've seen today — and it's hard not to be curious; hard not to want to be a part of it in some little way.
But then there's a lot to dislike about Rockstar, such as their union-busting antics, the shameless physical release that is not actually a physical release, the exorbitant price they're charging, particularly for the "Ultimate" edition, and the fact there's a monthly subscription program and microtransactions — granted, the latter two only really apply to Grand Theft Auto Online at this point, but we all know very well they will make their way into Grand Theft Auto VI's take on Online before long.
I think part of me is sort of afraid on some level that if I do decide to check out Grand Theft Auto VI, that will make me a hypocrite, given things I have previously said, and that I will be judged as such. On the other hand, it really is no business of anyone else what entertainment people choose to engage with in the privacy of their own home. The game is made; the decisions that led to its production have already been made; it has already been a big success. Me deciding whether or not I actually want to play it so I, for example, can talk about it with my friend who is enjoying it is not really going to make all that much of a difference.
So maybe I should play it. And then if I want to comment on it — or not — I can do so from a position of being informed, rather than making assumptions.
Hmm.
Want to read my thoughts on various video games, visual novels and other popular culture things? Stop by MoeGamer.net, my site for all things fun where I am generally a lot more cheerful. And if you fancy watching some vids on classic games, drop by my YouTube channel.
If you want this nonsense in your inbox every day, please feel free to subscribe via email. Your email address won't be used for anything else.
Who could have possibly predicted that the release of supposedly The Most Important Video Game of All Time would attract the sort of rancid, toxic discourse, the likes of which we haven't truly seen for many years? Everyone. Everyone could have predicted this. But it is both mildly surprising and inevitably depressing that it is just the same old talking points over and over again.
I'm not going to get into the specifics of the things that are being said, because they are the same old, same old bullshit that has been coming up since the dawn of time… or at least the Internet. Actually, earlier than that, because a significant part of it all has been, of all things, review score discourse. Yes, people are still arguing about the completely arbitrary number that certain publications put at the end of their reviews.
I'll spoil something for you here: these numbers are picked pretty much entirely on vibes. There is no science to it and there is certainly no consistency between publications. I watched an excellent episode of the FunFactor podcast recently where they looked at an Australian games magazine, and said mag regarded the entirety of the 0-49% mark as "bad". That's half of the entire grading scale! Other publications, meanwhile, make a point of saying that "50% is average", whatever "average" means… and then inevitably don't stick to it, because neither Metacritic nor the general public believe that something rated 50% or lower has any redeeming features whatsoever.
It's all so thoroughly silly, and it's been both humorous and depressing to see how predictable the talk has been. Complaining over frame rate? Check. Complaining about "woke"? Check. Complaining about reviewers getting paid off? Check. It's like we're back in the early 2000s. Only, somehow, worse.
Actually, I'm not sure that's fair. The 2000s, for me, represented one of the best times to be talking about games online. It was the heyday of 1up.com, still my favourite gaming site of all time (and not just because of the family connection). 1up.com did something that no other games site has succeeded at doing in quite the same way: it allowed subcommunities and subcultures to form, and those subcommunities thrived without feeling the need to arbitrarily declare war on one another for no real reason.
I think it was a little later that the absolute worst of Online Discourse started. I suspect it coincided with the rapid growth of social media, and the way in which clout-chasers could "earn" validation by posting the most inane garbage, designed to rile people up.
Although that's always happened, too, hasn't it? I remember when we first got "The Internet" at home, and I started to learn some of the "lingo" that surrounded it — "flaming" and "trolling" have been around since the earliest days of Usenet and, I suspect, even bulletin board systems.
Maybe we, as human beings, just shouldn't be allowed to interact with people via any means other than face-to-face. Because, as the meme goes, a lot of people online are willing to say things behind a veil of anonymity that would get their fucking face caved in if they were to say it in "real life".
I'm not sure what my conclusion to all this is. Probably that everything sucks, and the longer time goes on, the more it feels like things stay the same or even get worse. Surely we're due an upswing of people not being shitty to one another soon…?
Not today, though. Not today.
Want to read my thoughts on various video games, visual novels and other popular culture things? Stop by MoeGamer.net, my site for all things fun where I am generally a lot more cheerful. And if you fancy watching some vids on classic games, drop by my YouTube channel.
If you want this nonsense in your inbox every day, please feel free to subscribe via email. Your email address won't be used for anything else.
To no-one's surprise, it has been revealed that Rockstar's upcoming Grand Theft Auto VI will be $80 on release for its regular version, and $100 for the "Ultimate" version, because of course there's an Ultimate version. Hilariously and/or tragically, the "Ultimate" version even goes so far as to lock you out of specific shops in the game unless you buy it — a decision that some poor Forbes writer in complete denial has tried to astroturf already. No, but honestly, it's fine — they're probably only going to put the Ultimate Edition-exclusive items in those stores, there will definitely be other stores you can use!
Oh, and on top of that, the "physical" release of the game is a code-in-a-box. Fuck off with that.
I can't think of many series that have managed to so very thoroughly turn me off as Grand Theft Auto. I absolutely loved the original one, from the moment my underage self bought the original big-box PC version from "First Compute" one lunchtime at sixth form. ("Ol' Richie", the guy who ran the shop, knew I was lying about my birthdate, but he didn't really care. My friends and I spent too much money in his shop for him to make a fuss.) I likewise adored Grand Theft Auto III (I never played the second one to this day) and quite liked Vice City, particularly its soundtrack, which I had the box set of CDs for.
The series started to lose me around San Andreas. There's no way of saying this that doesn't sound a bit racist, so I'm just going to say it, acknowledge that is what it sounds like, and attempt to explain myself: I found that game's focus on strongly black-coded urban culture to not only be difficult to engage with, but outright indecipherable at times. To put it another way, I had found Grand Theft Auto III and Vice City to be a lot more accessible, simply because I was more familiar with the tropes of "mafia-style" gangsterism that they both leaned heavily on; by contrast, San Andreas' central culture felt jarringly different to me the moment I started playing, largely because I was so unfamiliar with it. I had never watched any movies or TV shows that dealt with inner-city black urban culture — I hadn't even really listened to much in the way of contemporary black urban music at the time I played San Andreas — and thus being thrown into the deep end of it right from the start of San Andreas was… an adjustment.
There is, of course, a very strong argument to be made for using video games to immerse yourself in a culture that is different from your own — hell, I do it all the time with Japanese games — and in many respects we should look at San Andreas as quite admirable for unashamedly putting black culture front and centre at a time there was not nearly as much truly inclusive, representative media as there is now.
But two things. One, I'm not sure Grand Theft Auto as a series is the one to tackle this in the most respectful manner; I don't know enough about real-world urban culture, particularly from the 1990s, to know how "authentic" San Andreas was — or if it was, in fact, just riddled with stereotypes. And two, I, personally, a middle-class white dude, with everything that entails, just found San Andreas, at least in its early hours, to be so far outside of what I was familiar with, both in my life and in the media I had previously engaged with, that I found myself thinking about the game as a whole much less fondly than I had done towards Grand Theft Auto III and Vice City, even though there are a lot of ways in which San Andreas is, in theory at least, a "better game". I'm sorry, that's just how it is; I can't change my own reaction to a creative work!
Anyway, the upshot of all that is that after San Andreas, I was a lot more lukewarm on the series as a whole than I had been previously. When Grand Theft Auto IV came out, I didn't pick it up right away, and when I did pick it up, I found that I wasn't enjoying it nearly as much as I had done III and Vice City. Part of that was down to the different cultural context in which I was playing it, I feel; both III and Vice City were games I played while I was at university, so I also associate them with drunken nights out with friends that ended with collapsing back to my place to play either of those games until ugly o'clock in the morning. This is probably another reason San Andreas didn't resonate as hard, thinking about it; by the time that game came out, we'd all finished university, and thus we were no longer spending several nights a week around one other's houses playing video games together.
I never finished Grand Theft Auto IV, and never even tried its DLC. I thought about trying it again on more than one occasion, but I could just never really muster up the motivation for it. I don't know what it was; it just… didn't click with me at all, for some reason.
By the time Grand Theft Auto V first came out — which, let's not forget, was thirteen fucking years ago — I felt I was ready to try again, though. The new three-protagonist structure sounded interesting, and the online mode sounded intriguing, too. I gave it a go. I finished the single-player story. I had what I would describe as a moderately good time with that PS3 version, but it didn't have that magic for me. It felt too self-consciously edgy, like it was trying desperately to be taken seriously, but also wanted to combine that with the over-the-top satire that the previous entries had incorporated, and it just didn't really work for me. And all the fluff in it was… cool, I guess, but most of it felt like it was just there for the sake of it, rather than in an attempt to make a better game.
Online was even worse. Aside from the fact it just flat-out didn't work for quite a long time on console after release, the few times I tried later it on PC (I bought the PC version on deep discount later to play with friends more easily, as they didn't have consoles) were such overwhelmingly negative experiences that I had absolutely zero desire to spend any more time in it than I "had" to. And I didn't "have" to spend any time in it whatsoever.
What was so bad? Flagrant cheating, with nothing being done about it. Behaviour that went beyond the simple antagonism the game is built around, into malicious attempts to spoil other people's fun. Load times that were approximately sixteen years long. The complete inability to form a "party" with your friends, making it near-impossible to stay together between individual "events". And, woven into the very fabric of the experience, pay-to-win microtransactions.
Don't get me wrong, I had a few good times in Grand Theft Auto V's online mode, but those only really happened when we had a private friends-only session and just pissed about a bit. I won't deny that doing things like impromptu bicycle races across mountainous countryside, with one of us driving an enormous truck instead, were very enjoyable. Stepping into a public game, however, provided some of the most miserable online experiences I think I've ever had.
And then, of course, Grand Theft Auto V just would not fucking go away. It came to PlayStation 4 and Xbox One. Then it came again to PlayStation 5 and Xbox XBOX or whatever they're called now. More and more guff kept being added to the online mode, all in the name of getting people to pony up the cash for those odious "Shark Cards", because playing the game normally in order to earn your way to rewards was, very obviously, a chump's game.
I got to the point where I actively resented the sight of Grand Theft Auto V. It felt like it had become everything the series had once satirised, and worse. I had no desire to play it ever again.
I tried a few other Rockstar games along the way, too, and the only one of them that clicked with me was Bully, a post-San Andreas game that switched gears by placing you in the role of a teenager at a school in a small town, rather than a hardened criminal in a huge conurbation. I didn't enjoy Red Dead Redemption at all — at least partly because I've never found Westerns to be appealing as a genre — and have felt no inclination whatsoever to really explore the company's broader output since. (Max Payne was good, mind, though I've never really thought of those as "Rockstar games")
Grand Theft Auto VI is frustrating to me because it's being hyped up as some great Second Coming of Christ, to such a degree that game developers and publishers putting out games that are not Grand Theft Auto competitors in the slightest are terrified of releasing even vaguely near it. This, to me, just seems counter-productive; while I'm sure a lot of people are going to buy and play Grand Theft Auto VI on release day, there are plenty of people out there, I'm sure, who feel just like I do — sick to death of this goddamn series, and not looking forward to the inevitable flood of nothing but GTA VI articles we're going to get on the two and a half remaining video game journalism websites for months after it releases. Those people are going to want to play literally anything else on November 19th!
I'm pissed because not only am I sick of the sight of Grand Theft Auto, I'm also furious at how they're clearly exploiting the public with the pricing, garbage not-actually-a-physical-release and bullshit like locking in-game stores behind a $20 more expensive premium edition. I'm furious because people are still going to buy it and reward this nonsense, and no-one will learn a goddamn thing from it. It is the absolute worst example of the excesses of the top end of today's video game industry, and it's going to get away with it because it's "the most-anticipated video game ever".
And this, of course, is to say nothing of Rockstar's union-busting activities that they're currently fighting a legal battle over. But I'll leave that for people who understand such things better to discuss.
I'm aware that me having a little rant here is going to change nothing, and this odious game is going to sell gangbusters when it comes out. But I feel a bit better having said my piece now. And, outside of the game doing anything even more egregious than the shit that has been announced today, this is probably the last time I will mention it, or even think about it — and I'm certainly not going to try and stop anyone who has actually been looking forward to it from enjoying it.
I might silently judge you a bit, though.
Want to read my thoughts on various video games, visual novels and other popular culture things? Stop by MoeGamer.net, my site for all things fun where I am generally a lot more cheerful. And if you fancy watching some vids on classic games, drop by my YouTube channel.
If you want this nonsense in your inbox every day, please feel free to subscribe via email. Your email address won't be used for anything else.