#oneaday Day 773: Off the Beaten Path

20120301-225122.jpg

The astute among you who follow my gaming posts (which, yes, I'm aware constitute an overwhelming majority of these entries — I am a passionate gaming enthusiast and an occasionally-professional games writer, after all) will be well aware of the fact that over the last few years, I've been drifting further and further away from the "mainstream" in terms of the titles I've been playing. This initially wasn't a particularly conscious decision, but rather a reaction to the fact that I just wasn't enjoying myself with the supposedly "big" titles of the day. I haven't made it through any Halo games except the original and Reach, for example, and my few forays into Call of Duty have left me feeling by turns underwhelmed and insulted. Similarly, I've given up all hope of ever making it through the Assassin's Creed series since it seems as soon as I think about playing through the older titles, Ubisoft goes and announces another one. You know, like they did today. Bastards.

I can't quite pin down exactly when this shift in attitudes happened, but I do know that I've come across some truly remarkable games in the process. One of the most memorable of these is Recettear: An Item Shop's Tale, which I picked up as part of one of Steam's characteristically generous Indie packs during one of the service's many sales, and promptly played all the way through for 40 hours. This was something of a difference from my expectation, which was that the game would be a shallow, social game-style experience with little depth and no long-term appeal. How pleasantly surprised I was when it turned out to be quite the opposite — deep, fun, well-written (kudos to Carpe Fulgur's wonderful translation efforts — we're talking PS1-era Working Designs-quality work here) and immensely satisfying to play. And not an Achievement in sight, either.

The attitude that I've decided to take as a result of discovering brilliant titles like Recettear and numerous others like it a little way off the "beaten path" is to simply say "fuck it" to the mainstream, and explore the things that I'm interested in, rather than the titles which the media makes it seem you're "supposed" to be interested in. It's been a very long time since I consulted a review prior to purchasing a new game, instead relying on a combination of word-of-mouth, intuition and simple, immediate, visceral reactions to screenshots, descriptions and other media.

This philosophy has also been born from the original ideals of the Squadron of Shame way back in the 1up days. Our original remit as a group was as follows, and I quote directly from the original 1up club page, which still stands today:

Games of Shame. You know you have them. They sit in your closet, collecting dust: Little jewels that you always tell yourself you are going to play, but never get around to. Well, that's about to change, soldier. You've been drafted to join the Squadron of Shame. Here we, the elite members of the 1UP Radio boards, paratroop into the bargain bins and rescue the unappreciated games that deserve to be saved. From there we battle through the trenches as a squad. At the end of the day, we take a moment to break down what made the whole experience worth fighting for by sharing war stories, reflections, and cigars. But the fight isn't just on the front of retro games: Any game deemed "fit for duty" by command can be put on the pile. At the end of the day, the reason we fight isn't just to discover new experiences, it's to answer that simple and fundamental question: "Why do we play?" Now suit up. The pile awaits.

I've pretty much stuck by those ideals as the years have gone by, always preferring to check out things that are outside of the mainstream, far from the things that everyone is talking about. I can't help but feel you can have too much of a good thing in terms of game coverage, and this is a problem which is only compounded by the explosive growth social media has enjoyed over the last few years. By the time a big-name game comes out, there are very few surprises left due to the constant PR trickle of new screens, exclusive reveals, teaser trailers, live-action videos, behind-the-scenes developer diary videos, blog posts, interviews, features, podcasts, multiplayer betas and all manner of other things besides. And when the game does come out, everyone is talking about it on Twitter and Facebook, putting you at serious risk of spoilers — or at the very least, of a feeling of "saturation".

So rather than bitch and moan about the state of the mainstream, the iron-fist rule of unscrupulous PR agencies and publishers destroying interesting, outlet-unique coverage and games that I have little interest in playing, I'm simply going to ignore stuff that doesn't interest me and focus on things which sound intriguing. (I'm aware that this post may well constitute bitching and moaning about the state of the &c &c but… but… FUCK YOU, that's what. WAIT I DIDN'T MEAN IT, COME BACK, I STILL LOVE Y—)

And, subsequently, I'll cover them myself, right here. I may be late to the party on some titles, but in many cases, things don't stop being relevant just because of their age, particularly with the number of HD remasters, portable remakes and backward-compatible devices we've seen recently. Providing these games with a little exposure here — "little" being the operative word, since I'm well aware of the relatively miniscule amount of traffic this blog generates, and am perfectly happy with that fact — will make me feel better, because then I then know that there's someone out there (me) appreciating and giving some much-needed attention to titles which maybe don't have a massive marketing budget or an omnipotent PR organisation managing and coordinating all their coverage. And, as small as my audience here is, if I write something, then there will be people reading about these titles, too. And if just a few of those people think "hmm, that does sound interesting" then I can feel like I've done a good job somewhere along the line.

So if I blog about something which sounds interesting and you decide to check it out for yourself, be sure to let me know. I'd love to hear your reactions to titles such as Katawa Shoujo, To The Moon, Recettear, Xenoblade Chronicles, The Last Story and numerous others. Over the course of the next few days/weeks/months, I'm intending to catch up on a variety of PSP titles, starting with Corpse Party and following with the portable Persona remakes. So watch out for those entries soon, and be sure to let me know your thoughts on those games if you've also sampled their charms.

And if you're excited for Mass Effect 3, Assassin's Creed III or, God forbid, the rumoured Call of Duty: Black Ops 2, then don't let me stop you being excited — I'd actually love to hear about those games, from you, too. Just be aware I probably won't be joining you in playing them!

#oneaday Day 772: The Last Story: A Scoreless Review

20120301-001735.jpg

Japanese role-playing games, despite having been a mainstay of the console space for many, many years, have fallen somewhat out of favour with the mainstream recently. Even Square Enix's flagship Final Fantasy series doesn't carry the same cultural cachet it once did, with the latest two instalments in particular proving very divisive.

The most common complaint thrown around when criticising the humble JRPG is that it hasn't moved with the times, that it hasn't evolved, that it has become predictable. And while this is true to a certain extent — we're still typically helping whiny-voiced spiky-haired twerps use their total lack of personal magnetism to bring together a disparate group of individuals to save the world from a white-haired androgynous gentleman who wants to use the power of something that came from space and/or inside the planet to BECOME A GOD — it's not quite the full picture. But you have to look a little off the beaten track to find examples of the genre evolving in positive directions.

Three such examples can be found on the Nintendo Wii of all places, in the form of three distinct titles that have become known as the "Operation Rainfall" games, after the movement which has been gently but repeatedly prodding Nintendo to localise them and bring them to the West.

Xenoblade Chronicles came first, with a European release last year and a North American arrival coming in the next month. Offering a vast open world, a bajillion quests, charming British voice acting and quasi real-time combat, Xenoblade certainly wasn't the JRPG we know and love — and it was all the better for it.

Pandora's Tower, an intimate story about a relationship between a monster-slaying man and a girl who is turning into a monster, is the third on the list, with a European release set for this April, and no plans for a North American appearance as yet.

Meanwhile, The Last Story saw its European release in late February, with a North American release courtesy of Xseed Games following later in 2012.

The Last Story is notable for a number of reasons, chief among which is the fact that it's a new collaboration between Hironobu "Final Fantasy" Sakaguchi and Nobuo "The Music of Final Fantasy" Uematsu. That alone should be enough to pique the interest of any genre enthusiasts, but it may also be grounds for caution. After all, these two have been making JRPGs for years, so surely they must be stuck in their ways by now?

Thankfully, such caution is not warranted, for The Last Story is an inventive take on the JRPG genre that dispenses with almost every convention in the unwritten rulebook, replacing them with a streamlined, efficient, rewarding and fun experience that should be a part of every JRPG fan's collection.

The Last Story tells the tale of Zael and his friends, a band of mercenaries with diverse British accents brought to Lazulis Island at the behest of the local Count in order to slay some monsters. Over the course of the 25 or so hours it will take you to beat the main plot, you'll have seen political intrigue, fairytale romances, magic, mystery, comedy, creepiness, conflict, betrayal, tragedy and everything in between. The game's twisting, turning plot moves at a brisk pace and never once gets bogged down in excessive angst or overly philosophical nonsense. There's a section roughly halfway through where a couple of sections feel a little out of place in the context of the overarching narrative, but these remain enjoyable mini-adventures in their own right and are over relatively quickly.

The game's brisk pace is in part due to the way it is designed. Unfolding over a series of linear chapters, The Last Story's narrative is constantly moving forward. Dungeons tend to be straightforward and linear to navigate through, but it's not exploration you play this game for — it's combat.

And what a combat system. Blending elements of character action, stealth, third person shooter and real-time strategy games, it's a real treat. Controlling Zael directly, the player is able to move freely around the battlefield and unleash attacks on enemies simply by tilting the analogue sticks in their direction. As the game progresses, Zael unlocks a series of other abilities allowing him to quickly move around the battlefield, "diffuse" magic circles to provide special effects, and give specific orders to his allies. Meanwhile, said allies hold their own intelligently and realistically, following the player's lead and orders sensibly. Charge in head-on and the rest of the gang will support Zael. Fall back to a healing circle and others will join until everyone's back to full strength.

It's far from straight hack and slash, though. Some combats are over in seconds as Zael hides around a corner and lures enemies out one by one with a crossbow bolt to the leg followed by a devastating "Slash" attack. Others are more protracted, strategic experiences where the terrain comes into play. Mages or archers on high platforms bothering you? Chuck a bomb in their direction, or order your own mages to collapse the crumbling masonry they're precariously perched atop. Despite having to give these orders in real time while the battle continues to rage around you, The Last Story's combat never feels overwhelming, but frequently feels exhilarating. Only an occasionally-wobbly camera and a frame rate that struggles a little bit in large-scale battles mar the experience slightly.

Despite the Wii's much-maligned technical limitations, The Last Story is a glorious-looking game. All thoughts of this being "just a Wii game" or "only 480p" quickly blow out of the window when you see the fabulous visuals, blending a slight sepia tint with some excellent lighting and high-contrast HDR effects, providing a beautifully rich, sumptuous aesthetic. Character models are detailed and well-animated, with clothing and armour changing their appearance as you upgrade it over the course of the game. And the environments are packed with detail, making navigating the game's small but beautifully-crafted world a real pleasure.

It's where the game differs so drastically from the conventions of JRPGs that it becomes the most interesting, though, as lovely as the visuals are and as satisfying as the combat is. The narrative, for example, largely centres around a single city rather than the usual globetrotting adventure, and deals with a variety of very "human" themes — class discrimination, racism, ambition, greed and the lust for power — without descending into "bad guy turns into giant monster" territory. There's plenty of magic and mayhem in there to ensure we don't forget we're taking part in a fantasy story, but for the most part it knows when to rein it in and focus on the characters. A tip of the hat is also given to Western RPGs' fondness of giving the player "choice" in how to respond to situations, but in practice this is a little underused throughout, with the game typically gently nudging you down the "correct" path if you happen to pick the "wrong" option.

The treasure-hunting aspect of JRPGs has undergone a big change, too. There's a small selection of armour available, and all characters can wear whatever they like. All pieces start with equal statistics, too, with differences only becoming apparent once you start upgrading them with materials which can be looted from monsters and chests. You'll be wearing the same armour at the end of the game as you started with — albeit considerably upgraded with a variety of special effects and a gradually-increasing amount of visual badassness. Weapons, meanwhile, can be upgraded to a certain extent simply by spending money on them — but to unlock their latent special abilities and make them considerably more powerful, you'll often need to find specific crafting items.

And — here's The Last Story's killer blow for those tired of 100 hour epics only being that long because of the excessive amount of fighting — there's no grinding. That's right. No random encounters. No running around in circles to attract monsters. No hanging around an area just to beef up enough to beat the boss. Instead, certain dungeons have "summoning circles" available for you to use, allowing you to trigger a small fight and gain some experience if you want to. Doing so will make subsequent boss battles a little easier by powering up your characters somewhat, but it's never obligatory. Characters gain experience at such a rapid rate and combat is such a pleasure, however, that you'll usually want to take advantage of these opportunities when they arise.

I haven't even touched on the wide range of sidequests in Lazulis City, nor indeed the fact that Lazulis City is one of the most convincingly realised fantasy towns of any RPG ever. Nor have I mentioned the curious inclusion of multiplayer, in which players can take their own customised Zaels online to either cooperate with other players against tough monsters or compete against one another in competitive matches. And then there's the guy who rewards you with vegetables and cooking equipment to be used as weapons if you bump into enough people in the streets. The fact there's a sidequest whose sole reward is an army of adoring groupies who scream every time you go to see them. The "Prank Banana" ammunition for Zael's crossbow which causes people to slip over in comedic fashion. Despite being a relatively short game by genre standards, there's a ton of stuff here to enjoy, and it never outstays its welcome. Notably, too, the non-plot-related stuff is all totally optional, as rewards for completing mostly take the form of items which can be acquired elsewhere, a better sense of the game world and its inhabitants and, of course, a smug sense of self-satisfaction.

The Last Story is without a doubt one of the best JRPGs of recent years, and certainly one of the most inventive takes on genre conventions. Even if you've long given up on JRPGs due to frustration at their narrative, aesthetic and mechanical cliches, you'll find something to like here. It saddens me a little that as a limited-run niche Wii title it will likely never find a huge audience worldwide, but those who do give its charms a chance will find themselves amply rewarded with a truly memorable experience.

#oneaday Day 771: The Trouble With Kotaku Might Not Be Quite What You Think

20120228-123237.jpg

Yesterday, Internet Rage focused the full power of it's +5 Cannon of Ranting at Kotaku, and not for the first time. On this particular occasion, the problem was this article, by all accounts a rather obnoxious piece by comedian Kris Kail describing the fact that he supposedly managed to get laid several times in a room filled with Sonic the Hedgehog memorabilia.

The article drew heat for several reasons. Firstly, it was simply quite bad taste. Secondly, it was rather obnoxiously self-congratulatory, and a thinly-veiled attempt for Kail to sell more copies of his book Slacker's Paradise. Thirdly, and this is the thing that Kotaku has most commonly taken flak for in the last few years, it was really only tangentially related to video games.

Editor-in-chief Stephen Totilo took to Twitter shortly after it became very clear that reaction to the article's publication was almost universally negative. His response, though, was somewhat curious, as it seemed like he was apologising for something different to what everyone was upset about.

"The only person who has to apologize for stories on Kotaku is me," he tweeted. "It was my call to run the Sonic story. I had expected it to come off as funnier. That was an error of judgment. But, more significantly, I owe our readers an apology for okaying a story that implies all gamers are straight men. I should've caught that. It's no small thing. No article on Kotaku should make you feel that you don't count as a gamer. If one does, that is my fault and inconsistent with Kotaku values. I must also add that humor and writing about sex isn't off-limits at Kotaku. We just have to do it right and not forget our own standards."

While it's good that Totilo responded so quickly to criticism, certainly on my Twitter feed the fact that the article was supposedly assuming an all-straight male readership wasn't really the issue — rather, it was the poor taste and seemingly rather pointless nature of the article on a site which is supposedly about video games.

But that got me to thinking. What is Kotaku really trying to do?

Then a theory hit me. It became obvious what Kotaku seemingly wants to do, despite its half-hearted attempts to be "inclusive" to everyone. It wants to be a "men's magazine" a la FHM, Maxim et al, but one that focuses on games. Were the site to be branded as such and have the confidence in its content to say "yes, we are specifically aiming at a straight male demographic" then articles like the above actually wouldn't be all that out of place. Those who didn't fit into that core demographic might not enjoy that sort of content, sure — but if the site was obvious enough about its intentions, it wouldn't provoke nearly as much ire.

There's precedent for this sort of thing, too. A good few years back now, there was a short-lived magazine from PC Zone and Maxim UK publisher Dennis known as Escape. It focused on video games, Internet culture and the Web's formative years alongside the usual scantily-clad ladies found in more "general interest" men's mags like its stablemate Maxim. It's a real shame it's not around any more. There's actually arguably a place for a publication like that on newsstands today.

Because you know what? It was pretty good. It brought together Things That Men Like under one convenient header. Games. The Web. Girls. Sports. "Alternative" culture. It took a few risks with its content, too; most memorable for me was the occasion when they quasi-scientifically attempted to test the theory that video games were better than sex by wiring up my brother to a heart monitor and then making him have sex, wank, talk to a stranger, play a video game and bungee jump. Surely a high point in his career. (Bungee jumping "won", by the way.)

I can't help but feel that the "blog/news aggregator" format for gaming sites has had its day, and that the way forward is for outlets to specialise both in their content and their core demographic. Video game culture is all-encompassing nowadays, covering men, women, kids, adults, straight, gay, trans, nerd, enthusiast, casual, PC, console, any combination of identifying characteristics you might name. As awesome as that is for the cultural penetration and acceptance of gaming as a mainstream medium, it does mean that you start to get to a stage where you can't please everyone. So why not focus on a specific demographic? If you're up-front and honest about being, say, a "men's" site and focusing on content as such, those people who have no interest in straight male-focused content can move on to any of the bajillion other sites out there (it's not as if we have a shortage, after all) while those who enjoy that sort of thing can stick around without feeling "guilt".

Some sites are already wise to this. We have GayGamer.net specifically choosing to cater its audience towards (I quote) "boys who like boys who like joysticks and girls who like girls who like rumble pads". We have Gamers With Jobs specifically catering towards the older gamer who doesn't necessarily have the time to play everything but enjoys some mature discussion. We have Girl Gamer, specifically aimed at female players. And doubtless there are numerous others catering specifically to other markets, too.

So why doesn't Kotaku bite the bullet and make a bold shift in editorial direction, specifically stating that it is going to court the straight gamer market above all else?

The answer is sadly probably the most simple one. Hits. By attempting to be "universally appealing" (and, as we've seen, often failing) Kotaku aims to get the largest possible audience of people who are just interested in "video games" as a general, amorphous concept. More hits means more advertising revenue means the site can continue to grow and be a household name in gamer culture. At the same time, controversies such as that which occurred yesterday over this article attract people to the site, in much the same way as the Daily Mail posts deliberately contentious headlines in order to direct outraged traffic their way. Any publicity is good publicity, as they say.

It's a cynical view, perhaps, but it's also not an unreasonable assumption to make given Kotaku's recent history. Consider, however, something that Arthur Gies of Vox Games said on Twitter last night:

You know what brings people to content? Good writing. You know what else brings people to content? Outrage. Which would you rather support?

There is a place and a demographic for content such as the Sonic the Hedgehog piece we saw yesterday. But that place is not on a site which purports to be universally appealing to all gamers.

The solution to this is one of rebranding and targeting that specific audience without guilt or apology — but sadly, I can't help but feel it's a bit too late for Kotaku now.

#oneaday Day 769: Tricks of the Dead

20120226-235451.jpg

I finished Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective on iOS last night. I never played the DS original, so when I heard it was coming to iOS, I snapped it up without hesitation, played through the free chapters and immediately handed Capcom and Apple the £6.99 it took to unlock the rest of the game.

Ghost Trick, for those who are unfamiliar, is a puzzle/adventure game from the team at Capcom previously responsible for the Ace Attorney series, one of my favourite story-based franchises of all time. Rather than being heavy on the "visual novel" style gameplay a la Ace Attorney, in Ghost Trick you take a much more active role in proceedings.

To reveal too much would spoil some of the game's excellent twisting, turning plot, but suffice to say this: You are a ghost. You wake up next to a corpse in a junkyard on the edge of town. Understandably, you assume that the corpse is yours, but you have no memory of who you were or what you were doing in a junkyard. You also have no memory of who the panicked-looking redhead in the short skirt and kinky boots is. Thus begins a lengthy adventure as you struggle to unravel the mystery of your own identity while piecing together the events of the night which led up to your death.

The gameplay primarily revolves around the use of the titular Ghost Tricks, which are where you possess an object and then manipulate it in some way. You're limited in your power, however, so you can only manipulate small objects (such as opening cupboards, rocking baskets, making candles flare up, that sort of thing) and in order to possess things, you can only move a short distance at a time, hopping from object to object. Thus part of the challenge becomes determining how you can make use of the environment to get to where you need to be.

There are two basic types of puzzle in the game — sedate puzzles where it's clear you need to make something happen when you can but there's no time pressure to do so; and puzzles where you have a strict time limit as you strive to use the objects in the environment to save someone's life. The latter tend to involve not only working out which objects to manipulate and how, but also timing your moves carefully to ensure things happen when they are supposed to. Failure isn't disastrous, however, as one of your ghostly powers is, conveniently, the ability to rewind time to four minutes before a person's death and try again — often with the ghost of the dead person in tow to offer advice or sarcastic comments along the way.

The game mechanics are relatively simple but the sheer variety of creative puzzles which they are used to create make up a considerable proportion of Ghost Trick's charm. The remainder of said charm comes from a truly loveable cast of characters, second only to Ace Attorney's motley crew in their appeal. The cast is small and introduced gradually over the course of the game's narrative, which means you get to know them all very well. They all have their own skeletons in the closet, however, and this allows for the biggest strength in the game's plot: surprise.

There are tons of surprises over the course of the whole story. The game uses its supernatural angle well to allow for uncanny things to happen, but never strays too far into the realm of total absurdity. Towards the end of the game, the sheer number of narrative threads and time-bending nature of the plot may seem a little convoluted, but sitting down and thinking about things for a moment makes it clear that it's a game which has been thoroughly planned and, within the laws of the game world set out by the story, makes sense.

£6.99 may seem somewhat expensive for an iOS game, but it's time people stopped thinking like that. £6.99 is a perfectly reasonable asking price for the amount of enjoyment you'll get out of this game, and considerably less than it cost upon its original Nintendo DS release.

So stop hesitating and just go download it now. It works on iPhone and iPad and even uses iCloud to let you transfer your save from one device to another. Grab a copy, sit down, relax and enjoy one of the best adventure games in recent years.

#oneaday Day 767: Probably Not the Last Post I Will Write About The Last Story

20120225-003815.jpg

The Last Story came out today in Europe. For the uninitiated, this is one of the "big three" Japanese role playing games that many are hailing as the Wii's last great hurrah before it goes off and has a well-earned break ahead of its younger brother's arrival. Said "big three" includes the already-released Xenoblade Chronicles, which is out in North America next month and which I have already discussed extensively elsewhere on this blog; The Last Story, which I will educate you on today; and Pandora's Tower which I confess to not knowing a great deal about at this time. The three games have little to do with one another save for the fact that they're published by Nintendo in Japan and Europe, though in North America it's a somewhat more complex situation.

It's hard not to see The Last Story as director Hironobu Sakaguchi and composer Nobuo Uematsu making a gentle jab at the Final Fantasy series which they both cut their teeth on, and which has now passed into the hands of a completely new team. Even the name means the same thing — Final Fantasy, The Last Story, do you see what they did there?

Far from being a throwback to these industry veterans' glory days, however, The Last Story manages to take the JRPG genre and, like Xenoblade Chronicles, give it a mighty kick up the rectum. It does this by taking almost everything you thought you knew about JRPG conventions and throwing it all out of the window.

The most obvious difference from "traditional" JRPGs is the combat system. While old-school JRPGs favour abstract turn-based systems, The Last Story's combat is somewhat closer to an action game. With elements of real-time strategy. And stealth games. And third-person shooter.

While that may sound like something of a mess, in practice it works very well. Here's how.

You take control of the game's protagonist Zael. Despite having a variety of weird and wonderful characters in your party and being able to equip them as you please, you're always in direct control of Zael. He can run around the battlefield, take cover behind objects, attack enemies, leap out from cover to do powerful "Slash" attacks, fire his crossbow, look around for structural weak points and order magic users to bring them tumbling down, release the power in allies' "magic circles" for various special effects and even — a little later, anyway — give direct orders to his allies.

Rather than thrusting the player into random combats a la Final Fantasy or having enemies scattered around the field a la Xenoblade Chronicles, The Last Story favours scripted battles which occur at predefined moments. This means that enemies have formations and arrangements which the player must study from the top-down view which pops up before each battle. Allies may offer suggestions on appropriate strategies in which to proceed, which may then be followed or ignored at will, as the party AI will react to how aggressive the player's approach to combat is.

The trouble with prescripted combat scenarios, however, is that it leaves little scope for level grinding or powering up characters, meaning that if a difficult situation presents itself later in the game, there's no means of beefing yourself up to make it easier. Or is there? Well, yes there is. The Last Story gets around this issue with occasional "Summoning Circles" at which it's possible to call up a group of enemies appropriate to the area the party is in and then kick the shit out of them. It's a slightly odd system, but it does at least get around the problem outlined above while avoiding frustrating random battles.

Outside of combat, there's plenty of interest, too. Like BioWare's divisive Dragon Age II, the game appears to largely be set in and around a large city rather than being a globetrotting adventure. Sure, you get to go off and visit other locations throughout the course of the story, but the city of Lazulis is very much a "hub" from which everything else extends, similar to how Kirkwall is in Dragon Age II.

Or, I should say, how Kirkwall should have been in Dragon Age II. Something just didn't feel quite "right" about the whole world we saw in Dragon Age II. Perhaps it was the copypaste areas. Perhaps it was the fact that all the residents of the city seemed to be perpetually standing around doing nothing. Perhaps it was the fact that you spent more time staring at the minimap than the 3D view itself. But Kirkwall didn't feel very "alive".

Lazulis, on the other hand, feels very alive. While the number of NPCs you can interact with directly is somewhat limited, there is plenty of "background colour" going about its business. Women scold children, guards patrol, merchants hawk their wares. And rather than being a passive observer, Zael slinks past people, squeezes down alleyways, shoves past people who are in his way when running, bangs his head on low-hanging signs and goes "ouch" and even has the option of tipping up fruit baskets and then watching in amusement as passersby slip over.

There's a ton to do in Lazulis even when not following the main plot, too. There's an arena in which to fight, plenty of sidequests to pursue and numerous hidden objects to collect. Rather than being a meaningless collection quest, however, said hidden objects provide the means of acquiring new items, upgrading weapons and gaining access to additional dyes for clothing.

Because last of all, The Last Story provides an impressive amount of character customization, particularly by JRPG standards. It's possible to dye each part of a character's outfit, remove certain parts of it to create the look you want and even to make certain parts invisible altogether. Couple that with the equipment upgrade system, which causes armour to change its physical appearance according to how much it's been worked on, and you have a band of heroes which the player feels they can truly take ownership of.

I'm about six hours into the game so far and having a blast. The gameplay is solid, the battle system is less bewildering and daunting than descriptions may make it appear, the cast is endearing (thanks in part to the use of English voice actors, much like Xenoblade), the graphics are lovely (not just "lovely for the Wii", but just plain "lovely") and the story is interesting. While you can clearly see it's a JRPG from the ludicrous haircuts that some of the characters are sporting, there's plenty of positive influence from Western titles here too — customization, choice and a good degree of freedom. I'm getting an inexplicable Baldur's Gate vibe from some of it — perhaps it's just the city-based medieval-ish political story.

I'll be looking forward to seeing what the game has to offer. In the meantime, if you're considering trading in that Wii that's been gathering dust for months — don't. At least not until you've played this and Xenoblade Chronicles. And, if the quality of these two titles is anything to go by, the upcoming Pandora's Tower.

#oneaday Day 763: A Question That No-One Seems To Have Asked Regarding RPGs

20120221-010149.jpg

Here's a stumper for all you RPG fans: exactly how much does taking one hit point of damage hurt?

It's not a particularly straightforward thing to work out, given that hit points are a representative abstraction of physical condition rather than a measurable, uh, measurement. But let's assume for a moment that it is indeed possible to measure one's own hit points. How much, then, would taking one hit point of damage hurt?

The answer to that question would largely depend on what model of hit points you are using. If you're talking Dungeons and Dragons hit points, taking one damage would fucking hurt if you're not in tip-top physical condition. The average "man in the street" sort of person (i.e. not a warrior, rogue, wizard, cleric or what have you) is regarded as a "level 0 human" and generally has something in the region of 2 or 3 hit points, if that. Level 1 wizards often only have in the region of 4 or so. As such, taking one hit point of damage as an average person following the Dungeons and Dragons model would hurt a great deal, putting you potentially up to halfway towards death (or rather, being knocked out, since people don't officially die until bleeding out to -10 hit points in D&D).

Compare and contrast with the JRPG approach to hit points, however, where totals frequently extend into the thousands and, in some cases, the tens of thousands. As a beginning character in a JRPG, you'll often have a low three-figure hit point total to start with, which will progress towards that elusive 9999 (or 99999) as you level up. Assuming that your average person hasn't really levelled up a great deal thanks to a notable lack of monsters (big spiders battled with Hoovers notwithstanding) we can work on the assumption that a single hit point's worth of damage doesn't really hurt a great deal. 'Tis but a scratch and all that.

So, since it's late and my brain is starting to shut down a little bit, let's take this to the next logical extension and consider a variety of horrific injuries to determine exactly how many HP damage they'd do following the two approaches outlined above. We're assuming that the person being injured here is not a Destiny-chosen hero who has been infused by the power of the Goddess/branded by the fal'Cie/chosen by Fate/revealed to be the wielder of the legendary blade Monado but rather, say, that man who works behind the fish counter in Sainsbury's. As such, we'll say he has 4HP in D&D and 150HP in a JRPG.

  • Getting an electric shock off an escalator handrail — D&D: 0HP, interrupt current action in surprise; JRPG: 1HP electric damage.
  • Falling out of bed while asleep — D&D: 0HP, lose "Sleep" condition; JRPG: 1HP physical damage, lose "Sleep" condition, afflict with "Embarrassment" (special moves charge slower)
  • Walking into a coffee table — D&D: 0 HP, maybe stun for a turn, staggering randomly around the room going "OUCH"; JRPG: 1HP physical damage.
  • Paper cut — D&D: 0 HP, afflict with "very mild bleeding" status, lose 1HP every 500 turns unless the cut heals (use a bandage or roll a D20 every turn, on a number between 3 and 20, it heals naturally); JRPG: 2HP physical damage.
  • Accidentally grating your fingers while attempting to grate cheese — D&D: 0HP, afflict with "very mild bleeding status" as with "paper cut" above; JRPG: 1HP physical damage.
  • Stubbing your toe — D&D: 0HP, incapacitate for a turn, remove ability to use vocal components of spells and stealth due to yelling "FAAAAAAAHHHHK!"; JRPG: 3HP physical damage.
  • Having a cat that is standing on you decide that it needs to hold on tightly with its claws — D&D: 0HP, 50% possibility of affliction with "very mild bleeding" status as with "paper cut" above, movement forbidden (you've got a cat on you); JRPG: 3HP physical damage, afflict with Rooted (you've got a cat on you).
  • Inadvertently ripping off a toenail by catching it on something — D&D: 0HP, afflict with "bleeding" status, lose 1HP every 50 turns unless the cut heals (use a bandage or roll a D20 every turn, on a number between 8 and 20, it heals naturally); JRPG: 10HP physical damage, afflict with Slow.
  • Burning your hand on the handle of a poorly-insulated saucepan — D&D: 0HP, interrupt current action, forced shouting of obscenity breaks any Stealth-related effects; JRPG: 10HP Fire damage.
  • Standing on an upturned three-prong plug — D&D: 0HP, movement forbidden for 5 turns, remove ability to use vocal components of spells and stealth due to yelling "FUCK. Cunt! ARSE! SHIT that fucking hurts. AAAAARGH."; JRPG: 15HP physical damage, afflict with Rooted.
  • Banging your head on a low ceiling even after seeing a "mind your head" sign — D&D: 0HP, dazed for one turn. temporary reduction to Wisdom and Intelligence; JRPG:10HP physical damage, 10MP magic damage for a blow to the head.
  • Getting punched in the face by some drunk dude at a bar who thought you were eyeing up his missus but in fact you were trying to read the scrawled sign on the front of that fridge that said that the cheap drinks might actually be a bit out of date — D&D: 1HP; JRPG: 25HP physical damage.
  • Suffering any sort of trauma to the testicular area — D&D: 2HP (probably won't kill you unless you've just been punched twice by a drunk dude at a bar who thought you were eyeing up his missus, but it bloody hurts), stunned for 5 turns, temporary reduction to Constitution; JRPG: 50HP physical damage, afflicted with "Stop" status as you wheeze and cough in an attempt to recover your dignity.
  • Getting stabbed in the leg, whether accidentally or deliberately — D&D: 2HP, movement rate halved; JRPG: 50HP physical damage, afflicted with "Slow".
  • Failing to escape the unwanted affections of an amorous gorilla — D&D: Your adventure is over. You have been adopted by an amorous gorilla as its mate. Any attempt to escape will result in death. JRPG: Perform a badly-executed stealth/platforming sequence to escape.
  • Getting stabbed in the face — D&D: 5HP (you will likely bleed to an unhappy -10HP death), permanent reduction to Charisma; JRPG: 100-150HP physical damage.
  • Suffering an apparently successful attempt to behead you — D&D: 14HP; JRPG: 150HP
  • Getting the smackdown from an angry God/being hit with a planet by the final boss — D&D: 50HP; JRPG: 5000HP
  • Standing quite close to the epicentre of a nuclear explosion, you know, enough to get a good view and think "ooh, that's a bit hot, I wish I'd stood back a bit more" — D&D: 998HP; JRPG: 9998HP.
  • Standing in the epicentre of a nuclear explosion — D&D: 999HP; JRPG: 9999HP.

Should you find yourself suffering any of these injuries, though, fear not; for a good night's sleep cures all ills, as everyone knows. Unless you're already dead, in which case you'd better get on good terms with your local Cleric or purchase some Phoenix Down.

#oneaday Day 762: So, Should You Play Final Fantasy XIII-2?

20120220-012257.jpg

I've been playing Final Fantasy XIII-2 for most of today and am almost at the end. I have reached the final boss, in fact, though haven't beaten it as yet.

You are doubtless wondering whether or not it is worth playing this game, as you may have heard mixed reviews from around the Internet. I therefore present a list of bullet points which you may wish to take into consideration when deciding whether or not you actually want to pick up a copy and try it for yourself. I am going to present each point as neutrally as possible, as some people may react strongly one way or the other to each factor, and those reactions may not coincide with my own feelings!

I'm assuming at least passing familiarity with Final Fantasy XIII here.

  • The main story can be completed in approximately 25-30 hours, making it significantly shorter than a lot of other RPGs in this generation.
  • Following completion of the main story, there is a veritable shitload of stuff to do. Progress in the game is measured through your collection of 160 fragments. At my current point (final boss) I have 62. There is plenty more I can go back and do after the credits have rolled.
  • The main story is somewhat confusing, and all the more so thanks to its non-linear structure. The antagonist's motivations are not made entirely clear until the very end of the game.
  • You play the same two characters all the way through the game. Neither of them have particularly "personal" stories to follow, though there is an underdeveloped narrative thread regarding Noel's memories.
  • There is a squeaky-voiced companion character present throughout the entire game. It is a Moogle, true in every way to past incarnations in the series, right down to ending almost every sentence with "kupo".
  • Final Fantasy XIII's characters all put in at least one guest appearance throughout the course of the game, but only one plays a major role in the story.
  • When you meet Hope, he is older than he was in Final Fantasy XIII and seems to have got over his "issues".
  • The time travel mechanic is more of a location menu. There aren't any particularly clever time manipulation puzzles throughout the course of the game, though there are a few sections where you revisit the same areas in different eras.
  • There are puzzles in certain areas. These take the form of "anomalies" in which you have to complete one of three different types of puzzle — finding a route over a board of tiles which disappear when you step on them while collecting crystals; joining like-coloured crystals with lines to form pictures; and a complex clock-themed puzzle that requires either forward planning or a lot of patience.
  • The game does not hold your hand as much as Final Fantasy XIII-2. This is most apparent around about 15 hours in when you are given a quest to go and find five items throughout time out of a possible seven, and given only vague clues and a picture to help you locate them. Said items are almost invisible in the field, but the Moogle reacts to them when you are close.
  • There is a quest system, where certain characters will exchange a Fragment for completing a small task, which usually takes the form of either a fetch or kill quest. There is no means of visually distinguishing questgivers from just people you can normally talk to, though once you have accepted their quest they get a marker above their head and on the map.
  • Collecting set numbers of fragments rewards you with extra special abilities.
  • Gameplay has a much stronger focus on exploration and observation than Final Fantasy XIII's straight-line corridors.
  • The automap is good and tells you how much of an area you have successfully explored. There is a quest late in the game to 100% as many maps as possible. Areas which you visit in different time periods share map completion percentage.
  • The weapon upgrade system from Final Fantasy XIII is no longer present. Instead, certain new weapons which you purchase require certain components acquired from monsters.
  • The Crystarium level-up system is a little different to Final Fantasy XIII. Both Serah and Noel do "laps" of a single crystal formation rather than having a longer "map" per role. On a lap, they can distribute their levels across any of their available roles. On completion of a lap, they can either unlock another role, enhance the bonus of one of their existing roles or extend their Active Time Battle bar, allowing them to complete more actions in succession.
  • After 25 or so hours, I have maxed out 3 of the 6 possible roles for both Noel and Serah. Progress slows with each lap around the Crystarium, requiring more Crystogenesis Points (acquired by defeating monsters and recovering Fragments) for each level gained.
  • There's a monster collection and training aspect. You can equip up to three monsters at once, each one specialising in a single role. These can then be incorporated into the Paradigm system to create custom party lineups.
  • Monsters are levelled up by feeding them special items rather than spending CP. When a monster completes a lap of its own Crystarium, it starts requiring rarer and/or more expensive items to level up further.
  • Monsters can be renamed by choosing from a large list of preset names, and adorned with decorative items found throughout the game.
  • Content has been withheld for DLC. This is most apparent in the "casino" area, where asking an attendant to explain the card games pops up a window that simply says "reserved for future DLC."
  • The music is very good and features a mix of both brand new tracks and recognisable ones from Final Fantasy XIII.

So there you go. A series of facts about Final Fantasy XIII-2 which may assist you in the decision of whether or not you want to give it a go. For what it's worth, I've been enjoying it more than I thought I would at the bewildering outset, but it's not the strongest Final Fantasy there's ever been, not by a long shot. It is significantly better than Final Fantasy XIII in most respects, however, so those who disliked that may wish to give this one another chance.

I've got a few days to finish this off, and then a copy of The Last Story is on its way to me. Given that that game is made by many members of the old Final Fantasy team (notably Hironobu Sakaguchi and Nobuo Uematsu), I am very interested to see what it offers.

#oneaday Day 761: I Think They Were Lying When They Said "Final"

20120219-015407.jpg

In an about-face from recent activities, I've been playing a relatively mainstream game today in the form of Final Fantasy XIII-2. Despite being a big release, however, one could put forward the argument that the Final Fantasy series is actually becoming somewhat niche again thanks to mixed opinions on the more recent titles.

Said mixed opinions are largely due to the fact that here is a series that is absolutely not afraid to reinvent itself every so often — with varying results.

Up until Final Fantasy IX, you pretty much knew what you were getting — a traditional-style JRPG with random battles. Sure, each one had its own unique ability system, some of which worked better than others (FFV's Job system was a highlight for many, while FFVIII's ridiculously abstract Junction system was both needlessly overcomplicated and far too easy to game) but for the most part, you could rely on the fact that you'd have a lengthy quest involving dungeons, towns, a world map, an airship and eleventy bajillion random battles along the way which, from FFIV onwards, used the series' iconic Active Time Battle system, offering gameplay somewhere between real-time and turn-based.

It was said prior to FFIX's launch, however, that that particular game would be the last "traditional" Final Fantasy title. And in many ways, that game did feel like a farewell to the series, featuring numerous references to all the previous entries in the franchise, a great story, some lovable characters and an utterly bewildering finale. It was also to be the last Final Fantasy to grace the PS1.

Final Fantasy X, the first entry in the series to arrive on the PlayStation 2, shook things up. While it was still fundamentally an RPG with random battles, a lot of elements which people had taken for granted had changed completely. Gone was the traditional experience and levels progression system, replaced with the Sphere Grid, a flexible system that allowed for a degree of character customization — or a lot of character customization if you elected to play in the "Advanced" mode. Also gone was the traditional world map, with the whole game structured as one continuous journey through the world rather than jaunts through key locations punctuated with running across a peculiarly-scaled map screen. Also gone was the Active Time Battle system, replaced by a more cerebral turn-based system in which players could manipulate turn order with the use of certain abilities. It was a neat system, but Active Time Battle returned with Final Fantasy X-2 — itself a departure for the series by being the first ever direct sequel to a previous Final Fantasy game.

Final Fantasy X-2 was great. Some people hated it for the fact that its tone and attitude was so different to that of its predecessor which, despite all its changes, told a pretty good tale, despite having one of the most irritating main characters the franchise has ever seen. Some people hated it for the fact it was as camp as a row of pink tents. Some people didn't even give it a chance after seeing the seriously cheesy intro sequence. But beneath the girlish nonsense lay a deep JRPG with an excellent character development system that combined elements of FFX's Sphere Grid and FFV's Job system.

Then came Final Fantasy XI, which was an MMO. This caused even series mainstays to shy away, and also proved that Square Enix had a lot to learn about making MMOs. It was difficult, progress was painfully slow and its tech was rather janky — due in part to the fact it was a cross-platform release on PC and PS2 (and later Xbox 360). But somehow despite this it was still recognisable as a Final Fantasy on some level — particularly once you started getting into the story missions and boss fights. You'd be forgiven if you skipped this one, however, as it required a time investment that many players aren't able or willing to give. That said, it's still going relatively strong today, meaning there must be something there that people like.

Final Fantasy XII reinvented the series once again, taking a few lessons from Final Fantasy XI and applying them to a single-player game. Ditching the concept of random battles altogether, Final Fantasy XII took place in an open world divided into zones, much like an MMO, and saw combat taking place on the field. There was a far greater focus on exploration and freedom than in any previous Final Fantasy game (except, arguably, the very first one, which pretty much plonked you down in the world and told you to get on with it with nary a hint of coherent plot) and, for the first time in the mainline single player series, the game focused far more on game mechanics than plot. This wasn't a bad thing — it was great fun to play, and the new systems worked brilliantly — but the plot was rather lacking, ending up as a rather poor imitation of Star Wars without the space combat. It just wasn't a very interesting story, which caused it to suffer. This, coupled with the fact that the game was so fundamentally different to what people thought Final Fantasy was — despite the fact it had been continually reinventing itself since X — caused many people to treat it with a degree of caution. The soundtrack was a bit rubbish, too — a big deal in a series that was known for its stirring, memorable music.

And then came Final Fantasy XIII, the first "next-gen" Final Fantasy. Conscious of the fact that some JRPG fans had shied away from the Westernness of XII, XIII took on a much more traditional JRPG structure. It was linear for the most part, it featured battles which took place on a separate screen, it had a levelling system somewhat reminiscent of FFX's Sphere Grid and it had a strong cast of characters participating in a plot best described as "bewildering". It was certainly a spectacle to watch, and remains one of the best-looking games of all time to this day. Unfortunately, its extreme linearity coupled with the fact that it was still throwing tutorial messages at you by the time you were a good 20 hours into it caused many people to, again, respond negatively to it.

Now enter Final Fantasy XIII-2, a game where Square Enix seem to think they've learned from the mistakes of the past. And in some senses they have done — gone is the straight line corridor design of XIII and in are much more open-plan areas which require exploration to discover all their secrets, for example. But in some senses, they've taken a few steps backward, too — the plot, for one, which is complete nonsense, even for a Final Fantasy game. There's a lot of time travel, though it's not until a good while into the game that you start to see this used in an interesting manner with parallel timelines and whatnot. Chrono Trigger it ain't. For the most part, it's used as a bit of a lazy excuse for whatever disastrous event is afflicting the next location you go to — it's always "a paradox", and dealing with it usually involved beating the snot out of some giant monster. 16 hours in and this format is starting to change up a bit, though, so I'm hoping for a bit more variety later in the game. (Yes, obligatory disclaimer here: I haven't finished it yet.)

There's a few technical issues which mar the experience, too. While XIII was criticised somewhat for its relative lack of character interaction, it did at least have properly-directed and blocked scenes for all the important conversations. XIII-2 occasionally takes the lazy way out, with characters standing woodenly in place and flapping their mouths at each other. This wouldn't be so bad were it not for the fact that the character you aren't controlling at the time you initiate the conversation freezes in place when the conversation starts, meaning that if they're in a position where they block the camera, the entire cutscene might be watched through their back. And sure, Serah has a nice bum, but it's nice to see the faces of people you're talking to.

All that said, these considerations don't stop XIII-2 from being an enjoyable game. They stop it from being a truly great, essential purchase game, but they certainly don't stop it from being fun. The battle system is straightforward and satisfying (if a little easy for the most part) and there is certainly plenty to do — and usually plenty of options for things to do at any one time rather than forcing the player down a linear path, too. There's a lot to like and a bit to dislike. If you hated XIII, it's worth a look to see the changes that have been made. If you hate Final Fantasy or JRPGS in general, it's probably not going to change your mind. If you're one of the relatively few people who enjoyed XIII, you'll enjoy the new (if batshit crazy) plot with numerous guest appearances from recognizable characters. And if you passed up playing XIII because of its mixed reviews, you can still get an enjoyable experience out of this thanks to its "Beginner's Primer" feature as well as numerous explicit explanations of past events throughout the course of the game.

Were I to believe in review scores (which I don't, really) I would give it a solid 7. Good, not great. Worth playing, but not essential. Flawed, but enjoyable.

#oneaday Day 760: I Love You, Kana

20120218-012654.jpg

I'm on a bit of a "narrative-based games that challenge the conventions of what is 'normal' and/or 'acceptable' for video games to tackle" kick at the moment, if you can even have a "kick" in such a thing. So it was that I found myself playing Kana Little Sister recently.

"What is Kana Little Sister?" I hear you ask. It's another one of them visual novel type things from Japan, meaning lots of reading, occasional decisions to make, anime-style pictures and, in many (though not all) cases, some naughty pictures. If you want to check it out for yourself, you can acquire a legal copy that works on modern machines right here. Link is pretty much NSFW, just so you know.

It will probably not surprise you to note that there are likely to be spoilers ahead. Consider yourself warned. Spoileriffic stuff is below the break. All discussion here is based on a single playthrough which achieved Ending No. 6, aka "Live Now", aka "Intellectual Ending No. 3", so any and all spoilers will relate to that route only.

Continue reading "#oneaday Day 760: I Love You, Kana" →

#oneaday Day 757: SEX!

20120214-231602.jpg

Let's talk about sex. Sex in video games, to be exact.

I read this article over on Eurogamer today. It makes its point in a rather crude manner, noting that video games "can't do sex", going on to cite numerous examples including popular media's backlash against Mass Effect's sex scene and BioWare's subsequent retreat into their characters' underwear; sex-focused games such as 3D Sex Villa 2; Second Life's notorious sex industry (which likely accounts for a considerable proportion of that virtual world's economy) and numerous others.

But I sort of think that the argument in that article is a bit flawed. There seems to be something of a confusion in the distinction between "sexual content" and "porn". I don't think anyone is advocating the inclusion of outright pornography in our games, though this is often the assumption that mainstream media makes when news emerges of sexual content in a high-profile game. But the Eurogamer piece jumps from discussing Mass Effect's soft-focus sideboob to games that are just plain porn. There's no middle ground, it seems.

Or is there? Well, yes, but you have to look outside of the mainstream and outside of the pornographic games industry to find it.

Probably the most common example you'll find of this "middle ground" is in the dating sim/visual novel/eroge genre. I've played a few of these over the years for curiosity's sake and while some are just interactive porn stories (Paradise Heights springs to mind — there are no choices to make and a lot of fucking) others like True Love, Kana Little Sister, Three Sisters' Story and, yes, Katawa Shoujo use their sexuality as something more than just a titillating scene for players to jack off over or something deliberately provocative to attract the ire (and thus inadvertent publicity) of the mainstream media. (This latter interpretation is a cynical view, I know, but I've seen too much video game marketing over the last couple of years to believe it doesn't happen.)

Rather, these games use sexual scenes in context. Katawa Shoujo is perhaps the best example, with sex scenes proving to be a way for us to get to know more about the characters. We learn that Emi is adventurous and willing to try anything once; that Lilly, despite her prim and proper appearance, enjoys her sexuality; that Shizune is dominant in all aspects of her personality; that Misha is confused; that Hanako believes no-one will see her as anything more than a "princess" to be saved; that Rin craves intimacy, to find some way to connect to another person. All of these scenes feature explicit erotic imagery and text, but none descend into being porn — sex for the sake of sex. During the sex scenes with Rin, for example, there's a lot of philosophising about what might be going on inside Rin's confused, creative head. Lilly uses one of her sex scenes to show Hisao what it's like to be blind. Emi's "Anal." scene is endearingly awkward as only teenage sex can be. And Hanako's encounter with Hisao is faintly horrifying after the fact.

"I can't fap to this!" was the war cry thrown up by members of 4chan upon playing Katawa Shoujo, but that's not a bad thing — do you jack off every time there's a sex scene in a movie? No, because that's ridiculous. Sex doesn't equal porn.

The same is true to a lesser extent in True Love, another dating sim based in a high school, though in this instance it's a regular education institute rather than a special school. In True Love, gameplay revolves around managing the protagonist's schedule so he builds up a series of different statistics ranging from creativity to sportsmanship. Different statistics will attract different members of the game's cast, and this then sends you down their various narrative routes where, again, along the way you get to know them a whole lot better and, again, you get to shag them at least once in a scene that, while erotic, is more focused on characterisation than providing something for the player to get their rocks off to.

Three Sisters' Story actively punishes players for being promiscuous, though not until it's far too late to do anything about it. Throughout the course of the game's story, the player gets the opportunity to have sex with the three sisters in question, but also has the opportunity to turn them down, too. If the player elects to have sex with all of them over the course of the game, the story doesn't end well for our protagonist, even after he saves them from abduction. A degree of self-control on the player's part is required in order to get the best ending. Do they want the sexy scene now, or do they want the story to end well?

Moving out of the visual novel genre, Silent Hill is another series which has always used sexual imagery to striking effect. Rather than being outright explicit about it, however, it tends to make use of more abstract imagery, leaving the player to interpret things for themselves. At no point in the game do we see exactly what made Angela so wrong in the head, but we can interpret that it was sexual abuse from her father. At no point in the game does James speak about his resentment over his wife's illness depriving him of sexual gratification, but we can determine that from the appearance and behaviour of Maria, the various times Pyramid Head shows up and the grotesque mannequins who form the bulk of the game's enemies.

You can't fap to Silent Hill, in short.

Look at Catherine, too. The game's just come out in the UK so a whole new wave of reviews has been hitting. I was rather surprised to see at least a couple calling it out for not being daring enough with its visuals — i.e. not showing any tits, muff, cock and/or balls. Despite the game's focus on adultery, sexuality and adult relationships, there are no explicit sex scenes in the game, and nothing more than sideboob in the nudity department. But the thing is, there doesn't need to be. Catherine didn't need explicitly pornographic scenes to get across its point. Sex is a key theme in that game, but that doesn't mean we need to stop for a fuck break every so often. Sometimes implying something can be just as powerful as showing it and — God forbid — making it interactive: Heavy Rain's painfully awkward interactive sex scene says "HHNNNGGG" at this juncture.

So can games "do sex"? Why yes, yes they can. Unfortunately, those games which do do sex and do it well tend to be confined to the specialist interest, cult classic or underpromoted independent title department. So why don't we see large publishers taking more risks, producing more adult games with sexual themes and/or content?

Part of it is a marketing issue. Getting too explicit with the sexytime in a game will net a release an "Adults Only" rating from the ESRB, and that's a big no-no for a lot of game retailers, thus hurting physical sales for the publisher. Given the growth of digital downloads, however, at least part of this problem goes away — there's no shame in purchasing an Adults Only title online, and publishers can simply sell it themselves, which is generally a better deal for everyone involved anyway.

Part of it, too, is fear of backlash from the mainstream media and, subsequently, politicians who don't understand the first thing about the industry, assuming it to be toys for children. California had a narrow escape just last year, and it's doubtful that publishers want to take the risk of making the people in charge think that censorship of a creative industry still finding its feet is a good idea.

Do we "need" sex in games? If we want to explore the full gamut of human emotions in the interactive stories that we tell, then yes, we do. We need to get over the assumptions that everyone playing games is too young to be able to handle sexual content. We need to get over childish tittering at every sight of sideboob. We need to have realistic characters who have realistic relationships.

What this doesn't mean, however, is that we need sex in all games. And those games that we do have sex in should justify its inclusion somehow, otherwise we're right back to accusations of peddling porn again. Katawa Shoujo and its ilk are doing it right. Mainstream publishers could learn a lot from the risks that independent studios and those who tackle the development of a game as a creative rather than a technical or marketing project.

Who knows what the future holds? I certainly don't. But it's clear that the industry as a whole still has a lot of growing up to do as yet.