So apparently a bunch of the Internet has blacked itself out in protest against the insanity that is SOPA. It’s a move that I fully support and endorse, as SOPA is a piece of crap that, while (arguably) well-intentioned, is completely impractical with the digital world we take for granted today.
That’s all I’m going to say on the politics of the matter for the moment, since there are plenty of other commentators out there who can doubtless discuss it in much greater detail than me. As a Brit, too, I’m not someone who will be directly affected by the law, but as we all know by now, the proposed measures will have a knock-on effect that could throw the whole online world out of balance.
What I wanted to talk about was how Wikipedia’s blackout has affected the stupid people of the world. Not sure what I’m talking about? Give @herpderpedia a follow on Twitter and you’ll quickly see what the problem is.
Wikipedia is an excellent and useful resource, of that there can be no doubt. But the level to which people have come to rely on it is perhaps a little worrying. To some people, it’s almost as if Wikipedia is the only source of information. (People who think this are probably the same people who believe that Facebook is “the Internet”)
There are, however, many more sources of information in the world than Wikipedia. Many more sources of information in the world than the Internet, for that matter. (Engage Old Fart mode) When I was at school, we had no Internet. Imagine that, you teenage morons! No Internet! If I got a bit of homework to “research” something, then I had to pick up an actual book and look through it. I had to know my alphabet well enough to look stuff up, and I had to know how to spell the thing I was looking up. Dark times? Not really, it was the norm; we accepted it. When the Internet came along, it was a source of information in addition to the knowledge we had in books, not a replacement. When I presented that homework to the class, it was written in my own words, showing my understanding. It wasn’t a printout from Wikipedia.
And yes, when I worked as a teacher, on more than one occasion (more than ten, in fact) I received homework from students who thought that I wouldn’t recognise a printout from Wikipedia. It showed absolutely no understanding on their part besides the most basic of net-savviest — an important skill in today’s society, for sure, but not what I was looking for with the assignments in question.
Technology breaks. Open forms of media are unreliable. Every so often someone will come along and want to censor things. I’m not saying books are immune to these issues, but at least you can still read them when the power goes off.
SOPA sucks. Fortunately, it looks like it might not get through — though we’re still a long way off victory at this time. Instead of bitching about not being able to cheat at your homework, try opening one of those dusty old books on your shelf and looking up the thing you want to know more about.
Magic, isn’t it? Knowledge without electricity. Who would have thought it?
Discover more from I'm Not Doctor Who
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
I have no clue what SOPA is (cant look it up… wikipedia is down… Just kidding) but a great post. Amusing and informative… I like the old fart stuff.