The word “tropes” has taken on something of a pejorative meaning in recent years, but I find something oddly comforting about the use of common, established, recognisable tropes — particularly when it comes to Japanese entertainment. I also find it interesting that Japanese entertainment — both games and anime — is a lot more willing to fully embrace the idea of tropes as part of the medium’s language rather than attempting to hide what it’s doing.
Take the common character tropes, for example. In a typical “harem” situation (usually a male protagonist surrounded by female characters, one of whom is typically positioned as the “main” love interest, but the others of whom are optionally also either interested in the protagonist or the objects of the protagonist’s affections) you tend to have your tsundere, your kuudere, your childhood friend, your “princess” type, your genki girl and, depending on how many characters are involved, numerous others. And yet the predictability of this type of cast makeup, for me, doesn’t prove to be tiresome; quite the opposite, in fact. I enjoy being able to point to the various characters and say “well, she’s clearly… and she’s clearly…” because it provides a recognisable, established starting point for these characters that can then subsequently be built on over the course of the rest of the work.
Exactly how — or if — these tropes are built upon by the work depends entirely on the work in question. Some works embrace the established tropes wholeheartedly and make the characters into textbook examples of the character types they initially appear to be: a valid approach. Conversely, some works deliberately work to subvert the tropes they establish in their early hours with some surprising twists and turns for the characters: also a valid approach. And, for some archetypes, subversion of expectations is part of the trope itself: witness the tsundere, for example — usually frowning, overly defensive and, at times, somewhat aggressive — and how her character arc typically involves her “softening” and showing her deredere side. Or the yandere — quiet and meek, but with something seriously unpleasant festering inside that demure exterior. Knowing that at some point she’s going to strike doesn’t diminish the impact when it happens; if she’s a particularly well-disguised yandere, it’s even more shocking and surprising.
I’m a fan of tropes, then; I enjoy that feeling of comforting familiarity that comes about when I come across a new character and recognise their traits. And everyone has their favourites, too; for me, I must confess to having a soft spot for tsunderes, but I do also like a kuudere and there’s always something heartwarming about a nice childhood friends romance. And the older sister “nee-chan” type. And a cutie imouto. And… Oh dear. (Essentially, I think I’m saying that my ideal anime harem would be made up of the cast of My Girlfriend is the President.)
If you’ll excuse me, I’m off to bed to read TVTropes. (Warning if you’re at work: settling down for a “quick read” of that site is a good way to lose a few hours.)
Discover more from I'm Not Doctor Who
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Yeah I dunno. I don’t think I’ve ever used trope in a pejorative manner, nor have I really thought of it as such. I think when a trope becomes negative, I’m more likely to use cliche, if only because that tends to imply laziness or poor implementation in terms of a repeated theme.
Not really the point of your piece, I know. Just felt like babbling…