So, the third of the three “Operation Rainfall” titles is finally upon us here in the UK (well, technically tomorrow, but Amazon were good enough to ship it to me a day early), completing the Holy Trinity of Wii-based Japanese role-playing games that many are lauding as the real last hurrah of Nintendo’s system. (I’ve actually lost count of how many times people have referred to Wii games as the system’s “last hurrah” or similar, but with Wii U on the relatively near horizon, it might actually be true this time.)
Like its predecessors Xenoblade Chronicles by MonolithSoft and The Last Story by Mistwalker, Ganbarion‘s Pandora’s Tower is far from what you’d call a conventional JRPG. In fact, of the three titles, Pandora’s Tower is the least traditionally RPG-ish and will likely prove to be the most divisive due to its curious mix of game styles. That’s not to say it’s bad — far from it, in fact — but those coming in and expecting a traditional globetrotting adventure with a cast of loveable misfits will find themselves surprised by what they discover.
Pandora’s Tower tells the story of a pair of young star-crossed lovers named Aeron and Elena. Aeron, the player character, doesn’t say much besides the odd grunt and “yes” but is clearly devoted to Elena. Elena, meanwhile, has a bit of a problem; she’s cursed. And, as curses go, this one’s a doozy — she’s slowly turning into a slobbering monster with icky skin and tentacles wriggling out of her shoulder. Discovering the nature of the curse at a harvest festival, Aeron and Elena flee into the wilderness accompanied by a strange old crone named Mavda who inexplicably carries a jar on her back containing an enormous skeletal man who occasionally babbles indecipherable gibberish. Madva reveals that there is one way to break the curse — for Elena to eat the flesh of twelve “masters” who reside in twelve towers that make up an imposing-looking fortress hovering over a terrifying-looking abyss known as The Scar.
As you have probably surmised, this is where the player comes in. Elena, being rather delicate and demure when she’s not slobbering and betentacled, isn’t exactly equipped to go monster hunting, so it’s up to Aeron to take his improbably large sword, magic chain (provided by Mavda) and floppy hair (model’s own) into the aforementioned towers to defeat the masters, rip out their “master flesh” and feed it to Elena (who was, at least until this whole mess started, a vegetarian for religious reasons) in order to save her from a hideous fate. Simple, right? All in a day’s work for an almost-mute hero.
Gameplay evolves in several discrete sections, and it’s the combination of these factors that makes Pandora’s Tower such an original, distinctive experience. If you were to boil it down to video game math, then the following equation would probably cover most of what I’ve experienced so far:
(Castlevania: Lords of Shadow – Patrick Stewart) + Ico + Shadow of the Colossus * Zelda + dating sim = Pandora’s Tower
There are two main components to gameplay: dungeoneering and downtime. During downtime, the player may, as Aeron, hang out with Elena in their makeshift hideout, ask her about the lore of the world, shower her with gifts, feed her various meaty treats and throw her untranslated texts so she can make herself useful. Aeron may also call up Mavda, who appears to perpetually live outside the back door of the hideout, and buy things from her, get her to craft and repair items, get her to upgrade equipment and offload excess meat. She’ll also pay Aeron for any texts he’s found — including newly-translated ones from Elena — which provides the player with a decent income stream if they take the time to explore and discover things. That completionist’s nightmare — the “percentage completed” gauge — makes an appearance in the game’s menu so those who want to make sure they get the full experience can see at a glance how close they are.
All this downtime activity isn’t just for show — most of the Elena-related activity affects the couple’s relationship, and providing certain gifts also causes her to spruce up the hideout with her own personal touches. The game’s ending is supposedly determined by the relationship value between the two by the time the story comes to an end, so it’s in players’ interests to ensure that they keep their lady sweet.
Upon leaving the hideout and heading for one of the dungeons, however, gameplay takes a decidedly different turn. It becomes a combination of third-person combat and environmental puzzle solving. Aeron may attack beasties with his sword and unleash combos, but it’s the chain that provides the most interesting gameplay possibilities. By aiming the chain with the Wii Remote’s pointer (or the right analogue stick on the Classic Controller) and attaching it to enemies, environmental structures and all manner of other things, Aeron is able to cause all kinds of mischief. And there’s plenty of scope for creative silliness, too — try attaching one end of the chain to one enemy’s legs and the other to another enemy’s face, for example.
Aeron’s goal in each dungeon is, like a Zelda game, to unlock the boss chamber and then defeat said boss. Rather than relying on a huge inventory of items, however, the majority of the game’s puzzle solving comes from creative use of the chain. Sometimes you’ll be pulling levers with it, sometimes you’ll be throwing chunks of ore into soft walls to use as hooks to grapple on to, sometimes you’ll be tying sentient plants to pillars and chopping them to bits before they burrow into the ground. And you’ll often be using the chain to rip out gobs of flesh and other crafting ingredients from fallen enemies, because Elena’s curse isn’t waiting for you.
No, indeed — a timer in the corner of the screen shows the progress of Elena’s transformation. It can be reset by grabbing some tasty meat and taking it back to her, but this requires you to make your way back through the dungeon you’ve just battled your way through, then delve back into it once you’ve given her her treats. Fortunately, the dungeons are designed in such a way that progressing further in them allows you to set up various shortcuts, and knowing the layout of them a bit better also allows you to romp through them fairly quickly. Progress doesn’t reset upon leaving the dungeon, so it’s perfectly feasible to unlock the boss room, go back, feed Elena and then go kick some boss ass.
It becomes an exercise in time management — can you make it through the boss fight before Elena goes all tentacly? (Should she find herself going all tentacly, this does, as you may expect, have an adverse effect on the couple’s relationship.) Or should you play it safe and head back with a bag full of meaty treats? This constant weighing up of pros and cons is further exacerbated by the fact that Aeron can only carry so much crap in his bag at once, necessitating a return to the hideout every so often to offload junk or craft it into useful items. This does, however, provide an opportunity for Aeron and Elena to spend some time together and improve their relationship, so it’s not a wasted trip — though the traipsing back and forth may annoy some.
There’s a lot to do, but the dungeons (at least the two I’ve completed so far) are well-designed and satisfying to figure out. A real sense of urgency is provided by the curse timer ticking away in the corner of the screen, and I can only imagine how the intensity of this will increase as the dungeons grow in complexity. The story is told in a less “in your face” manner than a lot of other games, with a strong focus on the relationship between Aeron and Elena, and a lot of environmental storytelling through discarded notes and architectural design. It’s an intimate sort of game, by turns lonely and daunting in the dungeoneering segments and heartwarming when the couple is together. At its heart is the tale of a relationship between two people and the lengths people will go to for love — an experience that, so far at least, is altogether unlike any other Japanese role-playing game or action adventure that I’ve played in recent memory.
In short, it’s a fitting dénouement to the “Operation Rainfall” trio of titles — and to the Wii’s catalogue in general. It’s actually pretty remarkable that three of the best “core” games of the generation are on a system that many people denounce as being “kiddy”, “casual” or a waste of time — or dismiss outright for not being HD. Deprive yourself of these three games simply on the grounds that they don’t look as good as, say, Mass Effect 3 and you’re depriving yourself of three distinctive, bold and original titles that are the perfect antithesis to the “cookie-cutter” approach of triple-A development and publishing. I hope beyond hope that their small but loyal fanbases will be enough for these studios to be able to keep doing what they do.
Further thoughts on Pandora’s Tower will follow when I’ve beaten it. In the meantime, if you’re American, go pick up a copy of Xenoblade Chronicles before it becomes impossible to find, and be sure to support Xseed’s release of The Last Story — and whoever picks up Pandora’s Tower — when they show up later this year.
[Edit: Apologies — I misread some recent news that made it look as if Xseed was bringing Pandora’s Tower to the US later in the year. It seems the status of that title’s US release is still somewhat up in the air — but we can hope!]
Discover more from I'm Not Doctor Who
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
I’m definitely interested by the premise, and the game as a whole has finally made a blip on my radar.
I’ve listened to a couple of divisive podcasts that talked about the game, so I’ve been up in the air as to whether this is worth my time or not.
Are you going to write another post detailing the mechanics? I’m curious as to if the dungeon crawling and combat has any meat to them.
I will do, yes; I’ll put up some more conclusive thoughts on the whole game when I’ve beaten it. For now I’ll say this: the sword combat is functional — there’s combo attacks, charge-up attacks, blocking and dodging, plus the ability to upgrade your weapon to extend the maximum length of your combos — but it’s the stuff with the chain that makes it really interesting. Chain up an enemy’s face to blind them. Bind their legs to stop them moving. Tie them to another enemy to deal damage to both at the same time. Tie them to something solid to stop them moving. Grab them, swing them around and bash them into another enemy to kill them both — essential for armoured foes that the sword doesn’t work on. The fixed camera angles very occasionally make aiming the chain a bit fiddly, but knowing this, the game slows down time while you’re in “zoomed-in aiming” mode to allow you more time to hookshot the specific body part you’re after.
The dungeons are executed in a rather Zelda-ish manner — that is, there’s a definite path through them and you do things in a specific order. Rather than locating a “boss key”, however, you’re destroying chains that bind the boss’s door shut. In most cases, you can deal with these chains in any order you like — but you can guarantee there’ll be plenty of environmental puzzles on the way to your destination. The main twist on the Zelda formula is the time limit, which is yet to become a massive issue — but then I’ve only done two dungeons so far. I can imagine larger dungeons being tense experiences.
Going off your point about it being the antithesis to triple AAA, The Wii represented a great opportunity for developers who had tons of ideas and not enough money to do the best games that they can and there was some actual gems that came out of it. It bothers me that so many gamers blame Nintendo, abandon the system and yet, continue to buy the games that make Triple AAA development such a high risk area, leaving publishers to only support the same games in different packaging and then talk about how the industry should evolve.
I cannot wait til this game comes to America.
I love the formula! I had similar first impressions. I would perhaps add Monster Hunter or Demon’s Souls in there. There is a strong component of finding materials and crafting items and weapons with them. There is also a prominent “home” are with a place to store items for later.