I’ve now completed four out of the five Blackwell games from Wadjet Eye Games, and I’m a big fan.
It’s been particularly interesting to come to this series so soon after playing through Life is Strange’s disappointing conclusion, because although they are technically inferior, the Blackwell games’ scripts are light-years ahead of Life is Strange’s relatively mediocre writing. A true case of substance over style if ever there was one, with Blackwell’s simple pixel-art graphics thoroughly winning out over Life is Strange’s beautiful stylised visuals.
The two aren’t directly comparable, of course, dealing with rather different subject matter, so that’s the last comparison I’m going to draw; I simply wanted to make the point that you don’t necessarily need a big budget to showcase some excellent writing.
I’m going to refrain from spoiling the plots of the Blackwell games here because I thoroughly believe that any adventure game enthusiast worth their salt should play through all five of them. I will, however, talk about the series as a whole, and how it is constructed.
Blackwell isn’t marketed as an episodic game, but it effectively is one. However, each of its five installments is completely self-contained in its own right — you simply get more out of the whole thing if you’ve played them in order, particularly in the case of Blackwell Deception, which features numerous callbacks to all the previous installments.
One of the things that is interesting about the series is how it has expanded in scope and ambition as time has gone on. First game The Blackwell Legacy was relatively low-key, with only a few environments to explore, and all of them represented in rather simplistic graphics. Then as the series progressed, the scale of the stories being told expanded to more diverse locations, rendered in greater detail, though still maintaining the old VGA-resolution pixel art look.
Alongside the growing production values for each episode, a real effort has been made to make them feel distinct from one another. Most notably, the passage of time between the episodes is handled extremely well, acknowledging advances in technology over the time period of the setting. In the first game, for example, Rosa only uses her computer for word processing. In the third (the second is set in the ’60s and stars Rosa’s aunt rather than Rosa herself) she can use it to check her email (and other people’s email!), search the Internet and browse her perpetually “under construction” homepage. By the fourth game, she has a smartphone that can do Internet and email without having to return to her apartment.
What’s nice about this is that it has a gameplay impact as well as making the setting feel convincingly “alive”. It’s noticeably more convenient to do everything through Rosa’s smartphone in the fourth game, compared to the combination of her notebook and apartment-bound computer in the previous installments. And in the second episode, set in the past, you have to think about things in terms of how you would have gone about them in the ’60s, without the conveniences of the modern age.
Each of the stories — and the overall “super-narrative” that they contribute to — is excellent, with Rosa and her perpetual ghostly companion Joey growing as characters significantly over the course of the games, and their relationship with one another deepening. Both of them are still masters of spitting acid at one another by the end, of course, but by then it’s done with affection rather than the combination of distrust, curiosity and fear seen in the first episode.
The games also manage to spin convincing supernatural tales without going overboard. They’re believable, well-crafted and clearly have had plenty of thought put into them, with explanations for the strange goings-on trickled tantalisingly through the various stories while still maintaining some mysteries for the grand finale. And a clear effort has been made to ensure the series as a whole has a consistent mythology and setting: characters from previous games show up in subsequent ones — or perhaps their descendants in some cases — and the attentive will notice a lot of the same company names cropping up over time. Not everything is explicitly told to the player, either; many of these connections are left for the player to infer and interpret, making it all the more satisfying.
As you can tell, I’m thoroughly enamoured by the Blackwell series, and very much looking forward to playing through the final installment in the very near future. If you’re a fan of classic adventure games, I can highly recommend picking them all up. They’re well worth your time and money, and Wadjet Eye Games should be commended for keeping the point-and-click adventure flag flying high and proud.