One of the things that I’m finding most striking about watching through Star Trek: Deep Space Nine is how the show is, on the whole, willing to experiment with structure, presentation and the entire way an episode’s story is told. I don’t know if it’s just that I haven’t watched a really good TV show for a long while or if things really were a lot more ambitious in this regard in the ’90s; either way, I’ve found it very striking.
There are several episodes that defy the conventions of what I think of as “regular TV” — or perhaps it’s more accurate to say what I perceive as the “norms” of the show. The first of these that springs to mind is the early fourth season episode The Visitor, which is frequently held up as an example of the show at its absolute best. And interestingly, it’s an episode of the show where it’s at its least “sci-fi”, outside of one significant aspect.
Spoilers ahead, though this episode is nearly thirty years old at this point, so I’m going to assume most of you reading this who might be interested in watching it will have probably seen it by this point.
In The Visitor, we are introduced to an old man who lives by himself. It’s a dark and stormy night, and a young woman comes knocking at his door, seeking shelter from the rain. The old man introduces himself as Jake Sisko — but at this point, we, the audience, know Jake Sisko as the 18 year old son of the show’s lead, Captain Benjamin Sisko.
The old Jake explains to the young woman that at some point after he turned 18, his father died.
Boom. Right in there with the intrigue. Had Star Trek: Deep Space Nine really killed off its lead in the second episode of its fourth season? No, of course it hadn’t, and everyone watching knew that was the case. But it was still one hell of a way to get the audience’s attention prior to the opening credits rolling.
The Visitor continues with old Jake telling the story of what happened to his father — apparently an accident aboard the USS Defiant pushed Ben out of sync with reality, causing him to “time jump” at various intervals. He’d return to Jake for a while — sometimes a few days, sometimes just a moment — and Jake would be older, but he’d not have aged a day.
Long story short, Jake spends his life trying to figure out what exactly is going on with his father, and how he might be able to save him. Eventually he comes to the conclusion that the only way for him to prevent his father from springing through time, attached to him by an invisible thread, is for him to die. And so, it gradually becomes clear over the course of the episode, that old man Jake Sisko is going to die, and that this is the only way for Ben to return to his own time.
The way this episode is presented is beautiful. It cuts back and forth between Old Jake simply telling the story to his companion, and us actually seeing what was going on at various points in Old Jake’s “past” — including some delightful “aged up” takes on Dr Bashir and Jadzia Dax. It’s just so unusual and beautifully directed that it remains one of the most memorable episodes of the series to this day; I remembered it fondly from when I first saw it on VHS tape roughly when it was “current”, and it hasn’t lost any of its impact in the intervening years.
I’m now getting into episodes that are less familiar to me, because I drifted off watching Deep Space Nine partway through the fourth season. Not because I wasn’t enjoying it, but because I didn’t really have the money or space to keep investing in VHS tapes with just two episodes on each!
Recently, I watched an episode called Rules of Engagement, and this also does some interesting things with its direction. The concept of this episode is that Worf is facing a hearing for supposedly destroying a civilian vessel during a confrontation with the Klingon Empire, who are, throughout the fourth season, being A Bit Of A Dick, to put it mildly.
Similar to The Visitor, a lot of the narration takes place in the “present” through the words of the participants in the hearing, but it also cuts to scenes that are being remembered by the people involved and the witnesses. In these instances, there are situations where the characters are going about their business as they did back in the way, but narrating them as they go — and even speaking directly to the “viewer” at various points. Seeing a character in a TV show directly address you, as if you are a participant in proceedings — in this case, casting you in the role of one of the participants in Worf’s hearing — is quite unusual, and it’s used to striking effect in this episode.
I’m sure from some perspectives both of these framing devices can be looked upon as a little cheesy. But I was struck by both of them as being thoroughly unusual and interesting. Like I say, it’s entirely possible that I just haven’t watched any “good TV” for quite some time (I can’t remember the last series I watched from start to finish. Possibly Fringe? And that was years ago) and thus haven’t seen anyone being particularly ambitious with direction and storytelling. But it doesn’t really matter; what matters is that Star Trek: Deep Space Nine still stands out as spectacularly good television, even nearly 30 years later.
Want to read my thoughts on various video games, visual novels and other popular culture things? Stop by MoeGamer.net, my site for all things fun where I am generally a lot more cheerful. And if you fancy watching some vids on classic games, drop by my YouTube channel.
Discover more from I'm Not Doctor Who
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
