Anime is full of surprises and frequently subverts your expectations, prejudices and preconceptions. In few places is this more apparent than in the recent show Oreimo, also known as Ore no Imouto ga Konna ni Kawaii Wake ga Nai or, literally in English, My Little Sister Can’t Be This Cute.
Now, with a title like that, you’d be forgiven for thinking that this show is one of two things — or perhaps both. One: moe moe happy funtimes featuring a wacky little sister running around being cute. Two: incestuous “sister complex” story in which male protagonist ends up falling for his little sister through various shenanigans they get up to together. While I can’t speak for number two in the show as a whole — I’ve only watched four episodes so far, so I’m still half-expecting them to pull the frequently-used “but they’re not blood relations!” trope out of the bag (please don’t spoil it even if that is the case!) — number one couldn’t be further from the truth. Far from being a wacky show about nothing in particular as I expected it would be, Oreimo is, it turns out, an oddly personal show about being true to oneself and accepting each others’ idiosyncrasies.
The concept is fairly straightforward. The main character Kyosuke is a 17-year old high school student who has had a somewhat strained relationship with his 14-year old sister Kirino for some time now. The reasons why they have been struggling aren’t explained, at least at the start of the show, but it’s clear that there’s a certain degree of tension between them, whether that be the usual case of siblings resenting one another or something more. Kirino is a model student — she’s pretty, she’s popular, she gets good grades and she’s a top athlete — and she also makes a lot of money doing modelling work for various catalogues and magazines.
But she has a secret.
Early in the first episode, Kirino makes a bold move. She comes to Kyosuke’s room in the middle of the night, wakes him up and confesses something that she’s been hiding for a long time: she’s a secret otaku with a hidden closet full of anime, manga, doujinshi and eroge — all paid for with her modelling earnings — with a particular focus on one particular (fictional) magical girl show, and also on anything related to little sisters. Kyosuke initially isn’t sure how to react, but it becomes clear that Kirino wants his help, even though her own pride and somewhat tsundere nature prevents her from stating this outright. He agrees to help her work out how to handle her secret “addiction” and figure out what to do with her life, because the stress of leading a “double existence” is starting to take its toll on her, as she feels uncomfortable showing the world who she really is.
As the series progresses, Kirino learns to make friends who are into her secret hobby, and comes to trust them. Kyosuke watches with some degree of pride as he sees his little sister starting to open up and be herself, but it isn’t an easy ride — particularly when her two worlds start to collide as the siblings’ parents and Kirino’s non-otaku friends start to find out what has been going on. Kirino faces constant judgement and scorn from people who look down upon her hobby, and has a habit of becoming defensive and lying as her first reaction, often leaving Kyosuke to take the fall — something which he usually resigns himself to without complaining, even when it involves (as it frequently does) him being kicked in the testicles.
When it comes down to it, though, Kirino will often (eventually) stand up for herself and say what she believes in; she’s passionate about her hobby, and over time begins to accept the fact that there will always be people out there who will judge her for it — often without knowing anything about it. Kyosuke, meanwhile, comes to understand his little sister a bit better, and also becomes something of a focal point for all her friends and acquaintances when various problems arise.
The nice thing about Oreimo that I’ve seen so far is that, a little like the excellent series Welcome to the NHK, it deals with subject matter that divides opinion but does so without being judgemental or preachy about it. You don’t get the impression from watching the show that it specifically wants you to think that being an otaku is either okay or that it is vile and shameful; it simply presents things the way they are, places a strong focus on the concepts of people’s “public” and “private” faces, and others’ reactions to those faces. Far from being wacky, silly fun times, it’s actually proven so far to be an interesting, very human story that doesn’t hide behind moe shenanigans despite having, as the title suggests, a super-cute female lead. (It could probably do without some of the occasional curiously-angled shots of said super-cute female lead’s bum, admittedly, but… well, there’s not much you can do about that, really.)
Anyway. Thus far I’ve been enjoying it a lot, and am looking forward to seeing how it continues. Further reports will undoubtedly follow.
Discover more from I'm Not Doctor Who
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
