Comments on: 2106: Sex and Games Make Sexy Games...? https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/10/26/2106-sex-and-games-make-sexy-games/ Memoirs of a nobody Mon, 07 Apr 2025 08:35:00 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.4 By: RedSwirl https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/10/26/2106-sex-and-games-make-sexy-games/#comment-78 Tue, 27 Oct 2015 16:08:29 +0000 https://angryjedi.wordpress.com/?p=8089#comment-78 In reply to SigurdVolsung.

Forgot to mention this, but PlayStation and Xbox don't allow straight-up porn because they are closed platforms. Your DVD player or Blu-Ray player is an open platform where at most the hardware is regulated by a consortium of companies. Again, it's the same reason you don't see any on Netflix or iTunes. Steam itself is a closed platform within PC, which is an open platform. You want more freedom in what you play than consoles offer? Then stick to an open platform, which right now basically just means PC or Android.

]]>
By: RedSwirl https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/10/26/2106-sex-and-games-make-sexy-games/#comment-77 Tue, 27 Oct 2015 15:35:28 +0000 https://angryjedi.wordpress.com/?p=8089#comment-77 In reply to SigurdVolsung.

To be honest I just dropped into these comments to discuss this with Pete specifically, so I'd rather not drag this on too much.

The comments below talking about the definition of obscenity probably strike at the real truth of the problem. From what I've seen of the screenshots on this blog, explicit scenes with Makina in particular would probably be considered illegal in some countries at first glance because she looks like a small child. Even if it passed a "scientific or artistic merit" test, it's still considered too obscene to make it onto mainstream distribution channels. I think there's definitely a cultural barrier too. From what I can understand, Grisaia or other similar "eroge" seem to be the video game equivalent of romance novels. The distinction between "eroge" and "nukige" doesn't really exist in the west, partly because in the west this "interactive romance fiction" barely exists at all. Western mainstream content distributors are probably scarcely aware of it. The stuff on HBO, and the Witcher games, are simply a more well-known quantity in the west. Japanese visual novels will also probably remain a niche for the foreseeable future, like foreign art films or whatever. I think channels like MangaGamer and JAST are probably where you'll continue to get them uncensored.

As for the comments on "problematic" stuff, I'll just say I think people who think it's about sexual prudishness or puritanism are kind of missing the point. The problem some people have with a lot of outwardly sexualized depictions of women in games is a lot of them are put there purely for the enjoyment of male audience members. I haven't played Grisaia so I can't judge it. Pete says the sex in that game is integral to the story and that its female characters are given a lot of agency (which is what has always mattered in this discussion). Maybe someone else would look at it and determine it has elements still largely put there to titillate men. I would say this is certainly the case with games like DOA. It's not really about "what" sexual content is in a game, but "why" it's there. Plus, the desire has never really been to remove games made to titillate male customers, but to just make more games with more nuanced and purposeful depictions of women (and minorities) to balance things out. I would argue that strong female characters are a bit more common in Japanese anime and games than western games but many 1) are extremely niche, and 2) often come with a whole host of other problematic elements, mostly for a bunch of deep macroeconomic reasons I'd rather not discuss here. Maybe other people have called for a ban on loli stuff.

I think that's about as much as I'm willing to discussion in this comments section. I've already had parts of this discussion with Pete back at the Squad forums.

]]>
By: Pete Davison https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/10/26/2106-sex-and-games-make-sexy-games/#comment-76 Tue, 27 Oct 2015 14:19:12 +0000 https://angryjedi.wordpress.com/?p=8089#comment-76 In reply to SigurdVolsung.

"You can all be prudes and you can all be children, that’s fine, but stop trying to impose your will on those that do not conform to those beliefs."

I think that's the important thing here; not everyone is the same, and no-one should try to impose their will on others. Unfortunately, a call to "ban" something is an inherently stronger suggestion than to "allow" something, since banning something deprives someone of something, while allowing something affords people the opportunity to make a choice as to whether or not they want to engage with something. Sadly, the "ban" crowd are the ones with the loudest voices at present, despite their frequent protestations that "they're not trying to take our games away". Thankfully, there are enough people willing to fight back and stand up for what they believe in when it comes to freedom of expression.

]]>
By: Pete Davison https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/10/26/2106-sex-and-games-make-sexy-games/#comment-75 Tue, 27 Oct 2015 14:08:12 +0000 https://angryjedi.wordpress.com/?p=8089#comment-75 In reply to Nate Schoenfelder.

I actually agree with a lot of this, and I accept that I'm focusing entirely on video games here, because that's primarily where my experience and expertise lies.

I think the question we need to ask ourselves is why certain things are considered "obscene" when they're things that people do and don't get arrested for. A titwank, for example, is nothing to faint onto the couch over — lots of people do it and it doesn't hurt anyone, so why shouldn't we be able to depict it in media without the work in question becoming commercially unviable (or, at least, commercially unviable on mainstream platforms)?

I don't really have an answer for that, unfortunately; if we did, I wouldn't need to write pieces like this at all in the first place. It's just a bit frustrating for people like me — and the many other eroge enthusiasts out there — to have stuff rejected, lambasted or simply ignored purely by virtue of it being considered — unreasonably in many cases — as pornography.

The times are changing slowly, gradually; the fact I can even buy the 18+ version of Grisaia in English is a sign of progress. But we still have a ways to go, and I wonder what exactly we need to put in place for creators to be able to have a bit more "freedom" of expression while still being able to, say, protect the more vulnerable members of society from content they might not want to engage with.

]]>
By: SigurdVolsung https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/10/26/2106-sex-and-games-make-sexy-games/#comment-74 Tue, 27 Oct 2015 10:30:25 +0000 https://angryjedi.wordpress.com/?p=8089#comment-74 In reply to RedSwirl.

I have watched many movies on Netflix that are more explicet than most of the eroge that I've played, including Fruit of Grisalia. And Witcher 2 and 3 has more graphic sex than most, but general pales to Game of Thrones. Pete is correct about the double standard. But I'd rather they not apply that at all to Witcher games either. There is a difference between eroge and nukkuge but overall the treatment of anything sexual or nudity in our industry is more "problematic" than anything else. You can all be prudes and you can all be children, that's fine, but stop trying to impose your will on those that do not conform to those beliefs. But I hold the game companies just as responsible as the NeoGaf and Polygon political correctness machine. They shouldn't only cater to the churchnet. And platform holders have no business deciding what you should or shouldn't be able to publish. My DVD player doesn't tell me I can't watch porn, and I don't want my Steam library or PS4 to stop me from playing full on pornographic games either. That is none of their business.

]]>
By: Nate Schoenfelder https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/10/26/2106-sex-and-games-make-sexy-games/#comment-73 Tue, 27 Oct 2015 02:15:30 +0000 https://angryjedi.wordpress.com/?p=8089#comment-73 There's quite a bit to unpack here. I'm hesitant to even mention anything at all, but I tend to read a majority of what you post and find few people are willing to engage you with dissent or challenge your assertions.

The issue you describe here is complex, and I admit there is no simple answer as to how adult material should be marketed or sold. However, you are coming at the topic from an angle too narrow to progress the issue. Your concern is with video games, but the issue has more to do with depictions of sexual themes in all media. Media depicting sexual acts is judged in a binary fashion mostly because we have limited methods of regulating obscenity. Accounting for artistic merit and cultural norms is complicated when we are essentially deciding what media is viable in a public marketplace.

Let's use Grisaia as an example. Although the original Fruit of Grisaia was, to the best of my knowledge, not rated by CERO, if it had been it would have likely been given the 'Z' rating. This is likely why the PSP and Vita releases were altered, as the sale of Z-rated games is heavily restricted. The question I'd pose is this: Given the original Grisaia's theoretical Z rating, is it pornography or art?

Many, yourself included, would consider it art. Although my experience with Grisaia is far more limited than yours, I would consider Grisaia art as well. Given this, should Grisaia, in its original form, be available for sale in all markets?

Probably not.

Although Grisaia has artistic merit, in its original and unadulterated form, it fails certain obscenity clauses in both the East and West. For example, the scene you have depicted here, even in context, would not pass scrutiny. If Grisaia were a film depicting this scene, it too would be given a commercially-prohibitive rating in both Japan and abroad. Does this prohibitive rating diminish the artistic merit of The Fruit of Grisaia? Not at all. Would it limit the number of theaters showing Grisaia? Absolutely.

The concern you address extends far beyond video games. Whether mainstream marketplaces should be obligated to sell "obscene" material with artistic merit is complicated. The artistic value of a piece of media is not dictated by its commercial viability. These concepts are mutually exclusive, and extend into every medium.

The issue you have isn't with Steam, or Sony, or the culture of interactive media. The issue you have is with the definition of obscenity, and it is much, much larger than games.

]]>
By: RedSwirl https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/10/26/2106-sex-and-games-make-sexy-games/#comment-72 Tue, 27 Oct 2015 01:33:22 +0000 https://angryjedi.wordpress.com/?p=8089#comment-72 I would imagine eroge isn't on Steam or other digital distribution platforms for the same reason you can't watch adult movies on Netflix or buy them on iTunes. Mainstream distribution platforms quite simply don't host adult entertainment. By western standards, eroge is probably considered simply a lighter shade of porn. Like a lot of things in Japanese culture, maybe it's a nuance that just doesn't exist in western languages.

As for the difference from western games that display explicit sex acts like The Witcher 3, I imagine most people see those games as on the same level as the explicit sex you might see on and HBO show, Game of Thrones in particular. In those cases sex is often part of the story, but not really a main draw, and explicit depiction is basically never a hugely important component. It's kind of just there. You could censor Witcher 3 (as it actually was in Japan) and the meaning still get's across.

As for other Japanese games that show lots of skin, I'd just chalk that up to the manner of depictions in each case. Dungeon Travelers 2 in particular is seen as problematic because, well, the characters in question look like children to many people. The company that localized it was probably afraid it would run into actual legal problems by pushing it out uncensored. In the case of Fatal Frame V I feel like any publisher other than Nintendo would have left the costumes untouched, but Nintendo remains an extremely cautious publisher that wasn't even willing to give FFV a retail release outside Japan or release the previous game in English at all. It went in minimal-risk. I chalk a lot of other examples and the publicity around them to just being the western media placing a magnifying glass on the meme that is "weird Japan."

]]>
By: SigurdVolsung https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/10/26/2106-sex-and-games-make-sexy-games/#comment-71 Tue, 27 Oct 2015 00:03:32 +0000 https://angryjedi.wordpress.com/?p=8089#comment-71 *applause* Good rant. I'm in your camp.

]]>