Comments on: 2058: Hi Games Journalism, It's Time We Had Another Chat https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/09/08/2058-hi-games-journalism-its-time-we-had-another-chat/ Memoirs of a nobody Fri, 27 Jun 2025 17:53:00 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.4 By: 2212: The Stat Connection – I'm Not Doctor Who https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/09/08/2058-hi-games-journalism-its-time-we-had-another-chat/#comment-2543 Tue, 09 Feb 2016 19:43:52 +0000 https://angryjedi.wordpress.com/?p=7859#comment-2543 […] response to Jim Sterling's dreadful and ill-informed review of Senran Kagura 2), Hi Games Journalism, It's Time We Had Another Chat (a response to Mike Diver's equally dreadful and ill-informed review of Senran Kagura 2, a […]

]]>
By: 2183: Why It Would Be a Mistake to Not Localise Valkyrie Drive Bhikkuni | I'm Not Doctor Who https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/09/08/2058-hi-games-journalism-its-time-we-had-another-chat/#comment-2542 Mon, 11 Jan 2016 13:44:43 +0000 https://angryjedi.wordpress.com/?p=7859#comment-2542 […] abuse that has been spewed at the Senran Kagura series in particular over the last few years — is both saddening and worrying, but perhaps understandable. To be honest, were I in […]

]]>
By: Pete Davison https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/09/08/2058-hi-games-journalism-its-time-we-had-another-chat/#comment-2541 Sun, 20 Sep 2015 17:28:03 +0000 https://angryjedi.wordpress.com/?p=7859#comment-2541 In reply to vince.

I don't give a fuck about Gamergate, myself. I give a fuck, however, about a supposedly respected critic (I say "supposedly"; I'd never come across him prior to this, and I sure won't be paying any attention to him after this) playing a game for less than an hour and feeling that he's in a position to pass any judgement on it whatsoever when he clearly has no understanding of its cultural context, its relevance to the series it's part of or its reason for existence.

]]>
By: vince https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/09/08/2058-hi-games-journalism-its-time-we-had-another-chat/#comment-2540 Sun, 20 Sep 2015 16:19:35 +0000 https://angryjedi.wordpress.com/?p=7859#comment-2540 In reply to nooneandnothing.

Nah, GamerGate exists to silence women, men and minorities asking for representation in their videogames. And to issue threats to them when they insists with their demands.

GamerGate also exists to make sure "gamers" can continue to enjoy games that objectify women. As recently seen in MGSV.

Fact is, rarely does GamerGate exist to ensure that there is ethics in journalism. And pro-GGers usually come out in suppport articles that fit their misogynist, homophobic or xenophobic agenda.

The world doesn't need a GamerGate. Not when articles like this one can STILL be made.

]]>
By: 2065: Some Thoughts for Critics | I'm Not Doctor Who https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/09/08/2058-hi-games-journalism-its-time-we-had-another-chat/#comment-2539 Tue, 15 Sep 2015 20:30:01 +0000 https://angryjedi.wordpress.com/?p=7859#comment-2539 […] too much because, to be honest, there's even less substance there than there was in Mike Diver's piece for Vice UK a little while back. Instead I want to talk about a more general philosophy that I think would be […]

]]>
By: 2062: By Request: 100 Reasons You Should Play Metal Gear Solid V | I'm Not Doctor Who https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/09/08/2058-hi-games-journalism-its-time-we-had-another-chat/#comment-2538 Sat, 12 Sep 2015 17:37:35 +0000 https://angryjedi.wordpress.com/?p=7859#comment-2538 […] established that it is acceptable for professional journalists to comment negatively about things without putting in a substantial amount of time with them — or in some cases, without even playing them at all — it's surely fine for some […]

]]>
By: judsgamereviews https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/09/08/2058-hi-games-journalism-its-time-we-had-another-chat/#comment-2537 Thu, 10 Sep 2015 07:34:00 +0000 https://angryjedi.wordpress.com/?p=7859#comment-2537 He's offended by the unresearched, incompetent REPORTING issue and rightly so. Re-read his post and you will see he clearly states that.

]]>
By: Mike Nieto (@Mike_Nieto) https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/09/08/2058-hi-games-journalism-its-time-we-had-another-chat/#comment-2536 Wed, 09 Sep 2015 03:35:55 +0000 https://angryjedi.wordpress.com/?p=7859#comment-2536 I wanna start by saying that yes, you are right in everything that you say. That review was really ignorant, hypocritic and just the tip of the iceberg of everything that is wrong with "game journalism". But I wanna point out a few things that I think are extremely important. When you like a game like Senran, you have to be in peace with the fact that it's gonna get mixed reactions. We usually criticize "SJWs" when they get offended or triggered by these things but to be honest, your reaction to the review is very similar to the reviewer's reaction to the game itself. You are getting offended by something that shouldn't matter to you, by something you should be ignoring.

Is Senran 2 suddenly gonna get worse because of that review¿ Is XSEED gonna take out a character or two because that man got offended by her¿ Of course not… Senran 2 will still be the same game that comes from a cool humble franchise that has only gotten better with every new entry. What I mean is, your enjoyment of the game should not be manipulated by what someone you didn't even know reviewed games said about it. Especially if it's a Senran game, which I repeat, will always get mixed reaction and that is something that we can't change.

When we, as potential players of the title find ourselves looking at articles like that, there are only two things you can answer with that will actually make a difference. 1) Buy the game, play it and enjoy it. As I mentioned, what that man thinks of Senran 2 should not change how YOU think about it. 2) Write your own review or find ones that actually speak the truth and share them in social media. Those two things are the only ones that will really counter the offended and triggered people.

Don't let that guy get into your nerves, he's not the first doing this and we definitely won't be the last. Just get the game, enjoy it and keep supporting the franchise as long as the games are good.

]]>
By: SigurdVolsung https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/09/08/2058-hi-games-journalism-its-time-we-had-another-chat/#comment-2535 Wed, 09 Sep 2015 00:34:59 +0000 https://angryjedi.wordpress.com/?p=7859#comment-2535 Wear modest clothes and get back in the kitchen, you are not attractive or a sexual being and you never should be viewed as such!

It's okay for me to say that, since I'm a feminist and I'm doing it for your benefit, women. It's okay to empower women, as long as you do it the way you are supposed to. And it's okay to be a man that likes women, but you must abide by Puritan ideals. Such is the age we are in. Much like the push and pull of liberal/conservative unfortunately while each side may be viewed as two sides of the same coin, when one side controls the lions share of discourse or shouts the loudest, you tend to find an unequal share of headlines.

]]>
By: llirium https://imnotdoctorwho.moegamer.net/2015/09/08/2058-hi-games-journalism-its-time-we-had-another-chat/#comment-2534 Tue, 08 Sep 2015 22:57:51 +0000 https://angryjedi.wordpress.com/?p=7859#comment-2534 The messages from the English-speaking media are loud and clear:

The sexiness of women depicted in the English-speaking world empowers women (so long as it's within "reason" or "tasteful") and the creators are fine, upstanding people. The sexiness of women depicted by Japanese creators (perverts!) is always bad and only for men to "gaze" at.

It's disgraceful and two-faced.

]]>